{
 "name": "The Atlas of the Middle",
 "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/",
 "creator": "Gabriel Lopez",
 "description": "Studies on middle managers and change, each with a plain-language summary, an evidence-strength grade and the parts of the Unfrozen Loop it informs.",
 "version": 2,
 "as_of": "2026-10-30",
 "count": 173,
 "license": {
  "name": "CC BY-NC 4.0",
  "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/",
  "covers": "The Atlas's own plain-language summaries, evidence grades and Loop coding, on the pages and in /atlas/studies.json. It does not cover the original papers, which stay with their authors and publishers. Commercial use (for example inside a paid product, platform or client deliverable) needs a license from Gabriel Lopez (contact via unfreeze.us/about/)."
 },
 "citation": "Cite as: Lopez, G. (2026). Atlas of the Middle. unfreeze.us/atlas/",
 "fields": {
  "id": "Stable identifier; the same as slug.",
  "slug": "The study's page name under /atlas/studies/.",
  "url": "The study's page on unfreeze.us.",
  "label": "Short citation label, e.g. \"Vuori & Huy (2016)\".",
  "title": "Title of the original paper.",
  "year": "Year of the print issue, as the study page gives it.",
  "journal": "Journal the paper appeared in.",
  "doi": "DOI link (https://doi.org/...), or null when the paper has none.",
  "source_url": "Link to the paper when it has no DOI, or null. A search link is labelled by source_url_kind \"search\".",
  "source_url_kind": "\"page\" or \"search\" for source_url, or null.",
  "kind": "\"study\", or \"commentary\" for a practitioner piece that is not a research study.",
  "design": "Study design, one of: archival, conceptual, experiment, mixed, other, qualitative case, qualitative interviews, review/meta-analysis, survey.",
  "grade": "Evidence strength: high, medium or low (an ordinal grade from the rubric at /atlas/#grading, not a score).",
  "loop": "Parts of the Unfrozen Loop the study informs: [{part, part_name, verdict}], verdict supports, mixed or challenges. Empty when it is about the middle in general.",
  "about_change": "true when the study is about a change, false when not, null for Version 1 records (coded only as a group: the dataset's about-change count includes them).",
  "summary": "Plain-language summary of the finding, written for the Atlas (not the publisher's abstract).",
  "atlas_version": "The Atlas version that added the study (1 or 2).",
  "added": "Date the study was added (YYYY-MM-DD), or null for Version 1 records."
 },
 "studies": [
  {
   "id": "vuori-and-huy-2016",
   "slug": "vuori-and-huy-2016",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/vuori-and-huy-2016/",
   "label": "Vuori & Huy (2016)",
   "title": "Distributed Attention and Shared Emotions in the Innovation Process",
   "year": 2016,
   "journal": "Administrative Science Quarterly",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0001839215606951",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "At Nokia, middle managers who feared their superiors and peers shared less bad news upward, while top managers, fearing competitors and shareholders, did not fully reveal how serious the outside threat was; leaders grew overly optimistic and the smartphone effort suffered.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "huy-et-al-2014",
   "slug": "huy-et-al-2014",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/huy-et-al-2014/",
   "label": "Huy et al. (2014)",
   "title": "From Support to Mutiny: Shifting Legitimacy Judgments and Emotional Reactions Impacting the Implementation of Radical Change",
   "year": 2014,
   "journal": "Academy of Management Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2012.0074",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Over three years of a radical change, middle managers went from supporting their top leaders to mutiny as they reassessed whether those leaders were legitimate, and their emotional reactions fed rising resistance.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "huy-2011",
   "slug": "huy-2011",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/huy-2011/",
   "label": "Huy (2011)",
   "title": "How middle managers' group‐focus emotions and social identities influence strategy implementation",
   "year": 2011,
   "journal": "Strategic Management Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.961",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In a three-year case at a large tech firm, executives treating strategy as a purely task-focused job unintentionally stirred middle managers' group identities around tenure and language; the resulting emotions saw managers, even ones executives promoted, back or quietly brush off an initiative.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "logan-and-ganster-2007",
   "slug": "logan-and-ganster-2007",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/logan-and-ganster-2007/",
   "label": "Logan & Ganster (2007)",
   "title": "The Effects of Empowerment on Attitudes and Performance: The Role of Social Support and Empowerment Beliefs",
   "year": 2007,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-6486.2007.00711.x",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "experiment",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "At a large trucking company, a randomized empowerment program (38 treated and 30 control managers) raised unit managers' sense of control only where they felt their own bosses supported them, and it also lifted their units' measured performance.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "azambuja-and-islam-2019",
   "slug": "azambuja-and-islam-2019",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/azambuja-and-islam-2019/",
   "label": "Azambuja & Islam (2019)",
   "title": "Working at the boundaries: Middle managerial work as a source of emancipation and alienation",
   "year": 2019,
   "journal": "Human Relations",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0018726718785669",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Middle managers at a Brazilian accounting firm saw themselves as proactive, reflective agents yet also as lacking autonomy and belonging, and routinely shifted between active mediators and mere coordination devices.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "peters-et-al-2019",
   "slug": "peters-et-al-2019",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/peters-et-al-2019/",
   "label": "Peters et al. (2019)",
   "title": "Interactive profit-planning systems and market turbulence: A dynamic capabilities perspective",
   "year": 2019,
   "journal": "Long Range Planning",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lrp.2018.03.004",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P4",
     "part_name": "Review on a rhythm, then hold the pace",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Across 331 Australian firms, budgeting, forecasting and reporting routines in which top and middle managers interact were tied to stronger business-unit performance, and the link was stronger where markets were more turbulent.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "chen-et-al-2018",
   "slug": "chen-et-al-2018",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/chen-et-al-2018/",
   "label": "Chen et al. (2018)",
   "title": "High‐commitment work systems and middle managers' innovative behavior in the Chinese context: The moderating role of work‐life conflicts and work climate",
   "year": 2018,
   "journal": "Human Resource Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/hrm.21922",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In 113 Chinese manufacturing firms, high-commitment HR systems went with more innovative middle managers, but heavy work-family conflict weakened that link, less so where the climate made it easier to share family concerns.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "tarakci-et-al-2018",
   "slug": "tarakci-et-al-2018",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/tarakci-et-al-2018/",
   "label": "Tarakci et al. (2018)",
   "title": "Performance feedback and middle managers’ divergent strategic behavior: The roles of social comparisons and organizational identification",
   "year": 2018,
   "journal": "Strategic Management Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.2745",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In a Fortune 500 firm, middle managers' searching for and championing of new strategic initiatives was tied more to how they compared with peers and other units than to how they compared with their own past results.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "den-nieuwenboer-et-al-2017",
   "slug": "den-nieuwenboer-et-al-2017",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/den-nieuwenboer-et-al-2017/",
   "label": "den Nieuwenboer et al. (2017)",
   "title": "Middle Managers and Corruptive Routine Translation: The Social Production of Deceptive Performance",
   "year": 2017,
   "journal": "Organization Science",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.2017.1153",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "challenges"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Facing goals the authors describe as unrealistic, middle managers in a telecom desk-sales unit pushed their reps to game how sales were recorded, so real orders were misattributed and reported results overstated; upper management then cut the field sales force on the strength of those figures.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "chang-et-al-2017",
   "slug": "chang-et-al-2017",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/chang-et-al-2017/",
   "label": "Chang et al. (2017)",
   "title": "Transformational leadership and corporate entrepreneurship",
   "year": 2017,
   "journal": "Leadership & Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/lodj-10-2015-0219",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Across 55 units in 27 firms, units with more transformational leadership showed more corporate entrepreneurship, partly through members' shared belief that they could succeed together, and how strong that indirect link was depended on the firm's empowerment climate.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "alfoldi-et-al-2017",
   "slug": "alfoldi-et-al-2017",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/alfoldi-et-al-2017/",
   "label": "Alfoldi et al. (2017)",
   "title": "Firm Bosses or Helpful Neighbours? The Ambiguity and Co‐Construction of MNE Regional Management Mandates",
   "year": 2017,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.12287",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "At Unilever, regional mandates given to subsidiaries proved ambiguous; several units negotiated what they meant and reshaped their scope over time, with boundary-spanning middle managers doing the most intense sensemaking.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "heyden-et-al-2017",
   "slug": "heyden-et-al-2017",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/heyden-et-al-2017/",
   "label": "Heyden et al. (2017)",
   "title": "Rethinking ‘Top‐Down’ and ‘Bottom‐Up’ Roles of Top and Middle Managers in Organizational Change: Implications for Employee Support",
   "year": 2017,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.12258",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Employees backed change most when middle managers started it and top managers carried it out, yet that pattern was the rarest, about 3% of cases; change started at the top drew no more than average support, whoever carried it out.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "ou-et-al-2017",
   "slug": "ou-et-al-2017",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/ou-et-al-2017/",
   "label": "Ou et al. (2017)",
   "title": "When Can Humble Top Executives Retain Middle Managers? The Moderating Role of Top Management Team Faultlines",
   "year": 2017,
   "journal": "Academy of Management Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2015.1072",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Across 43 top teams, humble executives' link to satisfied middle managers was weaker when the top team was split by faultlines, and those faultlines also blunted how much dissatisfaction pushed managers to quit.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "guo-et-al-2017",
   "slug": "guo-et-al-2017",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/guo-et-al-2017/",
   "label": "Guo et al. (2017)",
   "title": "How middle managers manage the political environment to achieve market goals: Insights from C hina's state‐owned enterprises",
   "year": 2017,
   "journal": "Strategic Management Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.2515",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In four large Chinese state-owned firms, operational middle managers actively dealt with local political actors to hit market goals, and the authors suggest they were better placed for this bridging work than top executives or frontline staff.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "chen-et-al-2016",
   "slug": "chen-et-al-2016",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/chen-et-al-2016/",
   "label": "Chen et al. (2016)",
   "title": "How Does Executive Strategic Human Resource Management Link to Organizational Ambidexterity? An Empirical Examination of Manufacturing Firms in China",
   "year": 2016,
   "journal": "Human Resource Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/hrm.21797",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In a survey of 144 Chinese manufacturers, a teamwork-oriented HR system for executives was linked to firms better balancing new and existing business, partly through a more effective top team, and more so where middle managers shared more knowledge upward.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "spyridonidis-and-currie-2016",
   "slug": "spyridonidis-and-currie-2016",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/spyridonidis-and-currie-2016/",
   "label": "Spyridonidis & Currie (2016)",
   "title": "The Translational Role of Hybrid Nurse Middle Managers in Implementing Clinical Guidelines: Effect of, and upon, Professional and Managerial Hierarchies",
   "year": 2016,
   "journal": "British Journal of Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8551.12164",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In two hospitals, nurse middle managers first got clinical guidelines working, but in one, where they coped less well with pressure to meet regulations and save money, the change faded as old hierarchies reasserted themselves.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "wei-et-al-2015",
   "slug": "wei-et-al-2015",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/wei-et-al-2015/",
   "label": "Wei et al. (2015)",
   "title": "I will speak up if my voice is socially desirable: A moderated mediating process of promotive versus prohibitive voice.",
   "year": 2015,
   "journal": "Journal of Applied Psychology",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1037/a0039046",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Among 66 middle managers and 262 of their staff in five high-tech firms, employees who valued power distance felt less able to offer improvement ideas, a link that weakened when their boss delegated more.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "glaser-et-al-2016",
   "slug": "glaser-et-al-2016",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/glaser-et-al-2016/",
   "label": "Glaser et al. (2016)",
   "title": "Managing the Risks of Proactivity: A Multilevel Study of Initiative and Performance in the Middle Management Context",
   "year": 2016,
   "journal": "Academy of Management Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2014.0177",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "challenges"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Among 383 middle managers in a multinational, the tie between a tendency to take initiative and job performance was weaker for risk-takers, a gap that widened with high autonomy and narrowed in units with strong performance management.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "currie-et-al-2015",
   "slug": "currie-et-al-2015",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/currie-et-al-2015/",
   "label": "Currie et al. (2015)",
   "title": "HR Practices and Knowledge Brokering by Hybrid Middle Managers in Hospital Settings: The Influence of Professional Hierarchy",
   "year": 2015,
   "journal": "Human Resource Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/hrm.21709",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In hospital care for older people, nurse middle managers could pass knowledge down to fellow nurses but struggled to pass it up the hierarchy or across to doctors; without HR support, the authors warn, a 'broken' rather than 'broker' chain may result.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "eggers-2016",
   "slug": "eggers-2016",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/eggers-2016/",
   "label": "Eggers (2016)",
   "title": "Reversing course: Competing technologies, mistakes, and renewal in flat panel displays",
   "year": 2016,
   "journal": "Strategic Management Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.2412",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "After IBM's plasma display bet failed, middle-level champions framed the case for LCDs around business issues rather than technology, sidestepping the biases that follow a failure, helped by funding researchers could get from division managers as well as centrally; IBM went on to lead LCDs.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "heyden-et-al-2018",
   "slug": "heyden-et-al-2018",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/heyden-et-al-2018/",
   "label": "Heyden et al. (2018)",
   "title": "The Conjoint Influence of Top and Middle Management Characteristics on Management Innovation",
   "year": 2018,
   "journal": "Journal of Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0149206315614373",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "archival",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Across 33 organizations from 2000 to 2008, the tie between an operations-oriented top team and management innovation was stronger when top and middle managers had similar professional backgrounds; age and gender similarity showed more complex patterns.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "thomas-and-ambrosini-2015",
   "slug": "thomas-and-ambrosini-2015",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/thomas-and-ambrosini-2015/",
   "label": "Thomas & Ambrosini (2015)",
   "title": "Materializing Strategy: The Role of Comprehensiveness and Management Controls in Strategy Formation in Volatile Environments",
   "year": 2015,
   "journal": "British Journal of Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8551.12075",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Among middle managers in volatile environments, comprehensive strategy-making and results-based and professional controls went with better implementation performance, while the authors argue that process controls may hamper strategy.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "hensmans-2015",
   "slug": "hensmans-2015",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/hensmans-2015/",
   "label": "Hensmans (2015)",
   "title": "The Trojan horse mechanism and reciprocal sense-giving to urgent strategic change",
   "year": 2015,
   "journal": "Journal of Organizational Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/jocm-06-2015-0084",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In a European merger, executives won fast buy-in by getting trusted old-guard insiders to vouch for the change, at the risk of resentment later.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "ou-et-al-2014",
   "slug": "ou-et-al-2014",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/ou-et-al-2014/",
   "label": "Ou et al. (2014)",
   "title": "Humble Chief Executive Officers’ Connections to Top Management Team Integration and Middle Managers’ Responses",
   "year": 2014,
   "journal": "Administrative Science Quarterly",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0001839213520131",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "mixed",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In 63 private Chinese firms, humble CEOs were linked to more unified top teams, and middle managers below them saw a more empowering climate and were more engaged, committed and better performing.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "kelly-et-al-2014",
   "slug": "kelly-et-al-2014",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/kelly-et-al-2014/",
   "label": "Kelly et al. (2014)",
   "title": "Changing Work and Work-Family Conflict",
   "year": 2014,
   "journal": "American Sociological Review",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0003122414531435",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "experiment",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In a randomized trial in a Fortune 500 firm's IT division, training supervisors to support staff's personal lives and prompting employees to rethink when and where they work modestly cut work-family conflict without raising hours.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "reitzig-and-maciejovsky-2015",
   "slug": "reitzig-and-maciejovsky-2015",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/reitzig-and-maciejovsky-2015/",
   "label": "Reitzig & Maciejovsky (2015)",
   "title": "Corporate hierarchy and vertical information flow inside the firm—a behavioral view",
   "year": 2015,
   "journal": "Strategic Management Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.2334",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "mixed",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In a European consumer-goods firm, each extra manager at the second-highest level was associated with roughly 10% fewer employee ideas passed upward; in a follow-up experiment with students, a sense of lacking control, far more than fear of judgment, explained the holding back.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "ahearne-et-al-2014",
   "slug": "ahearne-et-al-2014",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/ahearne-et-al-2014/",
   "label": "Ahearne et al. (2014)",
   "title": "Performance impact of middle managers' adaptive strategy implementation: The role of social capital",
   "year": 2014,
   "journal": "Strategic Management Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.2086",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Middle managers' influence on those above them related to unit performance along a curve rather than a straight line, and it paid off more for managers with a strong reputation in their networks.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "nielsen-and-riiskjr-2013",
   "slug": "nielsen-and-riiskjr-2013",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/nielsen-and-riiskjr-2013/",
   "label": "Nielsen & Riiskjær (2013)",
   "title": "From Patient Surveys to Organizational Change: Rational Change Processes and Institutional Forces",
   "year": 2013,
   "journal": "Journal of Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1080/14697017.2012.745584",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "mixed",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P4",
     "part_name": "Review on a rhythm, then hold the pace",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Across 100 Danish hospital wards, patient surveys tended to change practice when key professionals trusted the survey's quality, the ward scored worse than others, and the fix was obvious.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "agostino-et-al-2013",
   "slug": "agostino-et-al-2013",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/agostino-et-al-2013/",
   "label": "Agostino et al. (2013)",
   "title": "Leading change in public organisations: the role of mediators",
   "year": 2013,
   "journal": "Leadership & Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/lodj-12-2011-0123",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In an Italian court house modernisation, middle-manager 'mediators' translated leaders' ideas in three distinct ways, and the approaches differed in how well they turned those ideas into everyday work.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "halme-et-al-2012",
   "slug": "halme-et-al-2012",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/halme-et-al-2012/",
   "label": "Halme et al. (2012)",
   "title": "Innovation for Inclusive Business: Intrapreneurial Bricolage in Multinational Corporations",
   "year": 2012,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-6486.2012.01045.x",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In two multinationals, middle managers trying to build business models for poor markets worked around short-term profit pressure and unit-based incentives by creatively bundling scarce resources from inside and outside, which the authors call intrapreneurial bricolage.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "mollick-2012",
   "slug": "mollick-2012",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/mollick-2012/",
   "label": "Mollick (2012)",
   "title": "People and process, suits and innovators: the role of individuals in firm performance",
   "year": 2012,
   "journal": "Strategic Management Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.1958",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "archival",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Differences among individual people mattered more to firm performance than usually assumed, and variation among middle managers explained far more of the gaps between firms than variation among people in innovative roles.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "caza-2011",
   "slug": "caza-2011",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/caza-2011/",
   "label": "Caza (2011)",
   "title": "Testing alternate predictions for the performance consequences of middle managers' discretion",
   "year": 2011,
   "journal": "Human Resource Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/hrm.20410",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Across European R&D units, middle managers who felt freer to manage their own people tended to run better-performing units, though the link depended on the managers' experience and was limited by unit size.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "raelin-and-cataldo-2011",
   "slug": "raelin-and-cataldo-2011",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/raelin-and-cataldo-2011/",
   "label": "Raelin & Cataldo (2011)",
   "title": "Whither Middle Management? Empowering Interface and the Failure of Organizational Change",
   "year": 2011,
   "journal": "Journal of Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1080/14697017.2011.630509",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "At a large financial services firm, the authors trace a failed change initiative to closed-off executive and rank-and-file systems that left middle managers powerless, an outcome they link to the firm being bought out.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "hassard-et-al-2012",
   "slug": "hassard-et-al-2012",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/hassard-et-al-2012/",
   "label": "Hassard et al. (2012)",
   "title": "‘My Brilliant Career’? New Organizational Forms and Changing Managerial Careers in Japan, the UK, and USA",
   "year": 2012,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-6486.2011.01032.x",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Interviews with HR managers in large firms in Japan, the UK and the USA found most had downsized and delayered, promotions were scarcer and sideways moves more common, and middle managers were generally resentful.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "starke-et-al-2011",
   "slug": "starke-et-al-2011",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/starke-et-al-2011/",
   "label": "Starke et al. (2011)",
   "title": "Exploring archetypal change: the importance of leadership and its substitutes",
   "year": 2011,
   "journal": "Journal of Organizational Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/09534811111102274",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    },
    {
     "part": "P4",
     "part_name": "Review on a rhythm, then hold the pace",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "At a small manufacturer, most of a transformation happened after its champion CEO left and an unsupportive former CEO returned, with supervisors, staff and new systems filling the leadership gap.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "hope-2010",
   "slug": "hope-2010",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/hope-2010/",
   "label": "Hope (2010)",
   "title": "The Politics of Middle Management Sensemaking and Sensegiving",
   "year": 2010,
   "journal": "Journal of Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1080/14697011003795669",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In an insurance company's change effort, middle managers used their business expertise and political moves to steer how even their bosses understood the change.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "fu-et-al-2010",
   "slug": "fu-et-al-2010",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/fu-et-al-2010/",
   "label": "Fu et al. (2010)",
   "title": "Pursuit of Whose Happiness? Executive Leaders' Transformational Behaviors and Personal Values",
   "year": 2010,
   "journal": "Administrative Science Quarterly",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.2189/asqu.2010.55.2.222",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "mixed",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In Chinese firms, middle managers picked up on their CEO's personal values, and a CEO's inspiring behavior went with stronger commitment when the CEO cared about others and weaker commitment when the CEO was self-focused.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "thomas-et-al-2011",
   "slug": "thomas-et-al-2011",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/thomas-et-al-2011/",
   "label": "Thomas et al. (2011)",
   "title": "Managing Organizational Change: Negotiating Meaning and Power-Resistance Relations",
   "year": 2011,
   "journal": "Organization Science",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.1090.0520",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    },
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In a telecom company's culture-change workshop, senior and middle managers negotiated meaning in two very different patterns, set by how they talked to each other, which the authors relate to generative dialogue and to power and resistance.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "kellogg-2009",
   "slug": "kellogg-2009",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/kellogg-2009/",
   "label": "Kellogg (2009)",
   "title": "Operating Room: Relational Spaces and Microinstitutional Change in Surgery",
   "year": 2009,
   "journal": "American Journal of Sociology",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1086/603535",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In two hospitals answering new regulation, top managers backed new programs, but using them could require junior staff to challenge middle managers with opposing interests; change hinged on spaces where reform-minded middle managers and staff could band together.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "gong-et-al-2009",
   "slug": "gong-et-al-2009",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/gong-et-al-2009/",
   "label": "Gong et al. (2009)",
   "title": "Human resources management and firm performance: The differential role of managerial affective and continuance commitment.",
   "year": 2009,
   "journal": "Journal of Applied Psychology",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1037/a0013116",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In 463 firms operating in China, HR practices aimed at middle managers' performance went with better firm results, a link running through managers' emotional attachment to the firm; practices aimed at keeping them did not.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "yang-et-al-2010",
   "slug": "yang-et-al-2010",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/yang-et-al-2010/",
   "label": "Yang et al. (2010)",
   "title": "Middle Manager Leadership and Frontline Employee Performance: Bypass, Cascading, and Moderating Effects",
   "year": 2010,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-6486.2009.00902.x",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In three Chinese organizations, middle managers' transformational leadership was linked to better frontline performance two levels down, both directly and by rubbing off on the supervisors in between.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "mccann-et-al-2008",
   "slug": "mccann-et-al-2008",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/mccann-et-al-2008/",
   "label": "McCann et al. (2008)",
   "title": "Normalized Intensity: The New Labour Process of Middle Management",
   "year": 2008,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-6486.2007.00762.x",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In 64 interviews across five UK organizations going through large-scale restructuring, including delayering and downsizing, middle managers reported more autonomy but longer, more intense hours, closer monitoring and fewer promotion prospects.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "luscher-and-lewis-2008",
   "slug": "luscher-and-lewis-2008",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/luscher-and-lewis-2008/",
   "label": "Lüscher & Lewis (2008)",
   "title": "Organizational Change and Managerial Sensemaking: Working Through Paradox",
   "year": 2008,
   "journal": "Academy of Management Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2008.31767217",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "At Lego, middle managers charged with carrying out a major restructuring struggled for meaning; reflecting jointly with researchers brought their dilemmas into view as paradoxes, and the authors set out a process for working through them.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "zhang-et-al-2008",
   "slug": "zhang-et-al-2008",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/zhang-et-al-2008/",
   "label": "Zhang et al. (2008)",
   "title": "How do I trust thee? The employee‐organization relationship, supervisory support, and middle manager trust in the organization",
   "year": 2008,
   "journal": "Human Resource Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/hrm.20200",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Among 545 middle managers in China, support from their own boss was more strongly tied to trusting the organization than the employment deal was, strengthening trust's link to investment-style deals and weakening the negative link to purely transactional ones.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "mantere-2008",
   "slug": "mantere-2008",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/mantere-2008/",
   "label": "Mantere (2008)",
   "title": "Role Expectations and Middle Manager Strategic Agency",
   "year": 2008,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-6486.2007.00744.x",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Drawing on 262 interviews, Mantere argues the same role expectations can both free and limit middle managers' strategic action, depending on enabling conditions he identifies for each of four strategic roles.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "simons-et-al-2007",
   "slug": "simons-et-al-2007",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/simons-et-al-2007/",
   "label": "Simons et al. (2007)",
   "title": "Racial differences in sensitivity to behavioral integrity: Attitudinal consequences, in-group effects, and \"trickle down\" among Black and non-Black employees.",
   "year": 2007,
   "journal": "Journal of Applied Psychology",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.92.3.650",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Across 107 hotels run by one management company, middle managers who saw their senior bosses as keeping their word were in turn rated by frontline staff as more true to their own word; the link held for all employees and was somewhat stronger among Black employees, in cross-sectional survey data.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "laine-and-vaara-2007",
   "slug": "laine-and-vaara-2007",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/laine-and-vaara-2007/",
   "label": "Laine & Vaara (2007)",
   "title": "Struggling over subjectivity: A discursive analysis of strategic development in an engineering group",
   "year": 2007,
   "journal": "Human Relations",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0018726707075279",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "When corporate management used strategy talk to tighten control at an engineering group, middle managers answered with a strategy language of their own to keep room to act.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "hoon-2007",
   "slug": "hoon-2007",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/hoon-2007/",
   "label": "Hoon (2007)",
   "title": "Committees as strategic practice: The role of strategic conversation in a public administration",
   "year": 2007,
   "journal": "Human Relations",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0018726707080081",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In a public administration rolling out staff development, middle and senior managers shaped strategy not just in formal committee meetings but in informal conversations around them, where they built shared understanding, aligned on issues and pre-arranged support.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "noda-and-bower-1996",
   "slug": "noda-and-bower-1996",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/noda-and-bower-1996/",
   "label": "Noda & Bower (1996)",
   "title": "Strategy making as iterated processes of resource allocation",
   "year": 1996,
   "journal": "Strategic Management Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.4250171011",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P4",
     "part_name": "Review on a rhythm, then hold the pace",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Firms facing similar new-business opportunities ended up with different commitments: early results raised or lowered middle managers' enthusiasm and top managers' confidence in them, and repeated funding rounds escalated or wound down the bet.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "allen-et-al-2007",
   "slug": "allen-et-al-2007",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/allen-et-al-2007/",
   "label": "Allen et al. (2007)",
   "title": "Uncertainty during Organizational Change: Managing Perceptions through Communication",
   "year": 2007,
   "journal": "Journal of Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1080/14697010701563379",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "mixed",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Interviewed employees preferred supervisors for practical change information and saw senior leaders as the source of strategy; in a government department facing restructure, those rating change communication highly were more open to change, partly through feeling less uncertain.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "thakur-and-srivastava-2018",
   "slug": "thakur-and-srivastava-2018",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/thakur-and-srivastava-2018/",
   "label": "Thakur & Srivastava (2018)",
   "title": "From resistance to readiness: the role of mediating variables",
   "year": 2018,
   "journal": "Journal of Organizational Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/jocm-06-2017-0237",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In a survey of 276 Indian middle managers, trust, felt organizational support and emotional attachment to the organization helped explain the link between resistance and readiness to change, narrowing the gap between the two.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "chong-et-al-2018",
   "slug": "chong-et-al-2018",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/chong-et-al-2018/",
   "label": "Chong et al. (2018)",
   "title": "Two sides of the same coin? Leadership and organizational culture",
   "year": 2018,
   "journal": "Leadership & Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/lodj-05-2017-0122",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In a survey of 356 Chinese employees, different cultures lined up with different leadership, such as supportive leaders in team cultures and task-focused leaders in detail-oriented ones, with some support for leadership carrying culture's effect on outcomes.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "sull-et-al-2018",
   "slug": "sull-et-al-2018",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/sull-et-al-2018/",
   "label": "Sull et al. (2018)",
   "title": "\nNo One Knows Your Strategy -- Not Even Your Top Leaders.",
   "year": 2018,
   "journal": "MIT Sloan Management Review",
   "doi": null,
   "source_url": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/search?q=No+One+Knows+Your+Strategy+--+Not+Even+Your+Top+Leaders",
   "source_url_kind": "search",
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "other",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "A practitioner article argues that many managers, even top leaders, do not understand their company's strategy, explores why most organizations fall short on strategic alignment, and suggests how executives and middle managers can fix it.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "o-loughlin-2018",
   "slug": "o-loughlin-2018",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/o-loughlin-2018/",
   "label": "O'Loughlin (2018)",
   "title": "I Was Blind But Now I See: Various Ways to Provide System Sight",
   "year": 2018,
   "journal": "OD Practitioner",
   "doi": null,
   "source_url": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/search?q=I+Was+Blind+But+Now+I+See%3A+Various+Ways+to+Provide+System+Sight",
   "source_url_kind": "search",
   "kind": "commentary",
   "design": "other",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Reflecting on a 1995 Organization Workshop and work in the Singapore Public Service, a practitioner discusses how people can come to see their organization as a system, arguing for system-level partnerships and working with middle management communities.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "sharma-and-singh-2021",
   "slug": "sharma-and-singh-2021",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/sharma-and-singh-2021/",
   "label": "Sharma & Singh (2021)",
   "title": "Relationship of emotional intelligence with cultural intelligence and change readiness of Indian managers in the service sector",
   "year": 2021,
   "journal": "Journal of Organizational Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/jocm-05-2017-0193",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Among 109 middle managers in India's service sector, those scoring higher on emotional intelligence also tended to score higher on cultural intelligence and readiness for change.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "bardon-et-al-2017",
   "slug": "bardon-et-al-2017",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/bardon-et-al-2017/",
   "label": "Bardon et al. (2017)",
   "title": "Identity regulation, identity work and phronesis",
   "year": 2017,
   "journal": "Human Relations",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0018726716680724",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "At Disneyland, middle managers pushed back on a company script that put effectiveness ahead of ethics, recasting themselves as seekers of practical wisdom.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "cumberland-et-al-2018",
   "slug": "cumberland-et-al-2018",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/cumberland-et-al-2018/",
   "label": "Cumberland et al. (2018)",
   "title": "An emergent understanding of influences on managers’ voices in SMEs",
   "year": 2018,
   "journal": "Leadership & Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/lodj-09-2016-0222",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In a survey of 202 SME middle managers, bosses' openness to ideas went with higher job satisfaction and engagement, but only engagement was tied to speaking up more.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "tse-et-al-2018",
   "slug": "tse-et-al-2018",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/tse-et-al-2018/",
   "label": "Tse et al. (2018)",
   "title": "When and why does transformational leadership influence employee creativity? The roles of personal control and creative personality",
   "year": 2018,
   "journal": "Human Resource Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/hrm.21855",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "At a large foreign joint venture in China, frontline supervisors whose middle managers led in a transformational way felt more in control of their work and were more creative, with their own creative personality shaping that link.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "kryger-2017",
   "slug": "kryger-2017",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/kryger-2017/",
   "label": "Kryger (2017)",
   "title": "Strategy development through interview technique from narrative therapy",
   "year": 2017,
   "journal": "Journal of Organizational Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/jocm-06-2016-0111",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "A new purchasing department's manager and employees co-created its strategy in a storytelling workshop, with stories about the past shaping the mission and stories about the future the vision and action plan; the business area director then authorized it.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "courpasson-et-al-2017",
   "slug": "courpasson-et-al-2017",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/courpasson-et-al-2017/",
   "label": "Courpasson et al. (2017)",
   "title": "Politics of place: The meaningfulness of resisting places",
   "year": 2017,
   "journal": "Human Relations",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0018726716641748",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "challenges"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In two cases, middle managers took over and reshaped particular physical places, and the meaning they gave those places helped them build resistance to management policies and decisions.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "volberda-2017",
   "slug": "volberda-2017",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/volberda-2017/",
   "label": "Volberda (2017)",
   "title": "Comments on ‘Mastering strategic renewal: Mobilising renewal journeys in multi-unit firms’, Henk W. Volberda, Charles Baden-Fuller, Frans A.J. van den Bosch. Long Range Planning, Volume 34, Issue 2, April 2001, Pages 159–178",
   "year": 2017,
   "journal": "Long Range Planning",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lrp.2016.12.002",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "conceptual",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Revisiting his earlier work with colleagues, Volberda argues that big firms can renew through four kinds of journeys, emergent, directed, facilitated or transformational, each giving top, middle and front-line managers different roles.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "binci-et-al-2016",
   "slug": "binci-et-al-2016",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/binci-et-al-2016/",
   "label": "Binci et al. (2016)",
   "title": "Do vertical and shared leadership need each other in change management?",
   "year": 2016,
   "journal": "Leadership & Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/lodj-08-2014-0166",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    },
    {
     "part": "P4",
     "part_name": "Review on a rhythm, then hold the pace",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "At an Italian power utility's change program, top-down direction and a middle-manager change team's shared leadership worked together in every phase, with the balance between them shifting as the project's needs changed.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "pors-2016",
   "slug": "pors-2016",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/pors-2016/",
   "label": "Pors (2016)",
   "title": "‘It Sends a Cold Shiver down my Spine’: Ghostly Interruptions to Strategy Implementation",
   "year": 2016,
   "journal": "Organization Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0170840616655495",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In conversations at a Danish local government's strategy seminar, middle managers glimpsed darker futures behind the familiar strategy and voiced a sense that something different had to be done, though they could not say what.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "ren-and-zhu-2015",
   "slug": "ren-and-zhu-2015",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/ren-and-zhu-2015/",
   "label": "Ren & Zhu (2015)",
   "title": "Making sense of business leadershipvis-à-visChina’s reform and transition",
   "year": 2015,
   "journal": "Leadership & Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/lodj-03-2014-0047",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Repeated interviews with middle managers in Chinese state-owned, private and foreign-invested firms surfaced leadership patterns shaped by China's economic reform, some differing by who owned the firm.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "burgess-et-al-2015",
   "slug": "burgess-et-al-2015",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/burgess-et-al-2015/",
   "label": "Burgess et al. (2015)",
   "title": "Organizational Ambidexterity and the Hybrid Middle Manager: The Case of Patient Safety in UK Hospitals",
   "year": 2015,
   "journal": "Human Resource Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/hrm.21725",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In UK hospitals, clinician-managers balanced proven safety routines with new practice when they had professional legitimacy, strong networks and a broad view of their professional role.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "arnaud-et-al-2016",
   "slug": "arnaud-et-al-2016",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/arnaud-et-al-2016/",
   "label": "Arnaud et al. (2016)",
   "title": "Materializing Strategy in Mundane Tools: the Key to Coupling Global Strategy and Local Strategy Practice?",
   "year": 2016,
   "journal": "British Journal of Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8551.12144",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In one bank branch, a middle manager turned head-office strategy into everyday text-based tools that engaged frontline staff and produced the figures and indicators senior management's change objectives called for.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "ashford-and-detert-2015",
   "slug": "ashford-and-detert-2015",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/ashford-and-detert-2015/",
   "label": "Ashford & Detert (2015)",
   "title": "Get the Boss to Buy In.",
   "year": 2015,
   "journal": "Harvard Business Review",
   "doi": null,
   "source_url": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/search?q=Get+the+Boss+to+Buy+In",
   "source_url_kind": "search",
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "other",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Drawing on research into issue selling across organizations, Ashford and Detert give middle managers seven tactics for selling an idea upward: tailor it to decision makers, frame it around a strategic goal, manage emotions, time it well, involve others, follow the organization's norms and suggest solutions.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "gylfe-et-al-2016",
   "slug": "gylfe-et-al-2016",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/gylfe-et-al-2016/",
   "label": "Gylfe et al. (2016)",
   "title": "Video methods in strategy research: Focusing on embodied cognition",
   "year": 2016,
   "journal": "Strategic Management Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.2456",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "other",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Applying a video-analysis toolkit to middle managers during a large strategic change, the authors argue that much apparent shared understanding was emotional contagion, carried by managers' bodies as well as their words.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "bergstrom-et-al-2014",
   "slug": "bergstrom-et-al-2014",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/bergstrom-et-al-2014/",
   "label": "Bergström et al. (2014)",
   "title": "Paradoxifying Organizational Change: Cynicism and Resistance in the Swedish Armed Forces",
   "year": 2014,
   "journal": "Journal of Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1080/14697017.2014.938096",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Swedish Armed Forces unit managers met years of reforms with cynicism, which the authors read as a way of making sense of contradictions, not just resistance.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "harding-et-al-2014",
   "slug": "harding-et-al-2014",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/harding-et-al-2014/",
   "label": "Harding et al. (2014)",
   "title": "Who is ‘the middle manager’?",
   "year": 2014,
   "journal": "Human Relations",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0018726713516654",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Listening to middle managers talk about their work in focus groups, the authors argue they shift between going along with and pushing back on the standard manager role, both controlled and controlling.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "kim-and-mauborgne-2014",
   "slug": "kim-and-mauborgne-2014",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/kim-and-mauborgne-2014/",
   "label": "Kim & Mauborgne (2014)",
   "title": "Blue ocean leadership. (cover story)",
   "year": 2014,
   "journal": "Harvard Business Review",
   "doi": null,
   "source_url": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/search?q=Blue+ocean+leadership.+%28cover+story%29",
   "source_url_kind": "search",
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "other",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "A practitioner article describes how an unnamed retailer had executives and middle managers examine how they currently led, then design new ways of leading with input from employees.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "aksoy-and-bayazt-2014",
   "slug": "aksoy-and-bayazt-2014",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/aksoy-and-bayazt-2014/",
   "label": "Aksoy & Bayazıt (2014)",
   "title": "The Relationships Between MBO System Strength and Goal‐Climate Quality and Strength",
   "year": 2014,
   "journal": "Human Resource Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/hrm.21603",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Surveying middle managers in six Turkish firms owned by one family group, the authors found that a stronger management-by-objectives system went with a higher-quality, more widely shared goal climate in units, with how distinctive the system was mattering most.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "teulier-and-rouleau-2013",
   "slug": "teulier-and-rouleau-2013",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/teulier-and-rouleau-2013/",
   "label": "Teulier & Rouleau (2013)",
   "title": "Middle Managers' Sensemaking and Interorganizational Change Initiation: Translation Spaces and Editing Practices",
   "year": 2013,
   "journal": "Journal of Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1080/14697017.2013.822674",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Middle managers from five large French public works firms, meeting as a cross-company study group, made sense of a shared digital design model set to reshape their sector by translating and reworking ideas together.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "tippmann-et-al-2014",
   "slug": "tippmann-et-al-2014",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/tippmann-et-al-2014/",
   "label": "Tippmann et al. (2014)",
   "title": "Stimulating Knowledge Search Routines and Architecture Competences: The Role of Organizational Context and Middle Management",
   "year": 2014,
   "journal": "Long Range Planning",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lrp.2013.11.001",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "At Gamma, an ICT multinational built on replicating standard solutions, a loose structure and no central knowledge store went with middle managers running intense, cross-silo searches that pieced together answers to unusual problems.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "grandy-and-holton-2013",
   "slug": "grandy-and-holton-2013",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/grandy-and-holton-2013/",
   "label": "Grandy & Holton (2013)",
   "title": "Leadership development needs assessment in healthcare: a collaborative approach",
   "year": 2013,
   "journal": "Leadership & Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/lodj-11-0090",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "A leadership needs assessment with middle managers at an Atlantic Canada health authority, reaching about half of the program's 150 managers directly, surfaced considerations including making space for development, building partnerships, and mentoring and coaching.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "sharma-and-good-2013b",
   "slug": "sharma-and-good-2013b",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/sharma-and-good-2013b/",
   "label": "Sharma & Good (2013b)",
   "title": "The Work of Middle Managers:  Sensemaking and Sensegiving for Creating Positive Social Change",
   "year": 2013,
   "journal": "The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0021886312471375",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "conceptual",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "The authors argue that middle managers keep corporate social initiatives alive by making sense of, and explaining, the pull between profit and social goals, and suggest ways organizations can build those skills.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "tuan-2013",
   "slug": "tuan-2013",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/tuan-2013/",
   "label": "Tuấn (2013)",
   "title": "Underneath organizational health and knowledge sharing",
   "year": 2013,
   "journal": "Journal of Organizational Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/09534811311307950",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "A survey of 412 middle managers at Vietnamese shipping companies linked ethical corporate social responsibility to higher trust, which in turn tied into upward influence, organizational health and knowledge sharing.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "tippmann-et-al-2013",
   "slug": "tippmann-et-al-2013",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/tippmann-et-al-2013/",
   "label": "Tippmann et al. (2013)",
   "title": "The Two Faces of Knowledge Search: New Solutions and Capability Development",
   "year": 2013,
   "journal": "Organization Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0170840613485846",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "When middle managers hunted for knowledge to solve unusual problems, they produced new fixes and sometimes modified or created routines; the authors argue firms that organize for knowledge to circulate are better able to build capabilities this way.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "sharma-and-good-2013a",
   "slug": "sharma-and-good-2013a",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/sharma-and-good-2013a/",
   "label": "Sharma & Good (2013a)",
   "title": "The Work of Middle Managers",
   "year": 2013,
   "journal": "The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0021886312471375",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "conceptual",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "The authors argue that middle managers keep corporate social initiatives alive by balancing profit and social demands, and propose a model, illustrated with field data, of how they do this work and the capacities it takes.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "smollan-2013",
   "slug": "smollan-2013",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/smollan-2013/",
   "label": "Smollan (2013)",
   "title": "Trust in change managers: the role of affect",
   "year": 2013,
   "journal": "Journal of Organizational Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/jocm-may-2012-0070",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Interviews with 24 people about workplace change found that trust and distrust in supervisors and senior change leaders came loaded with emotion, distrust most intensely, and that perceived fairness built or eroded that trust.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "krausert-2014",
   "slug": "krausert-2014",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/krausert-2014/",
   "label": "Krausert (2014)",
   "title": "HRM Systems for Knowledge Workers: Differences Among Top Managers, Middle Managers, and Professional Employees",
   "year": 2014,
   "journal": "Human Resource Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/hrm.21554",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "conceptual",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "This theory paper argues that the HR systems that work best differ for top teams, middle managers and professionals, and that short-term pressure and favoritism in staffing can keep firms from adopting the effective ones.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "burgess-and-currie-2013",
   "slug": "burgess-and-currie-2013",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/burgess-and-currie-2013/",
   "label": "Burgess & Currie (2013)",
   "title": "The Knowledge Brokering Role of the Hybrid Middle Level Manager: the Case of Healthcare",
   "year": 2013,
   "journal": "British Journal of Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8551.12028",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "other",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Drawing on healthcare, the authors argue that hybrid middle managers who straddle clinical and managerial work play a strategic role passing knowledge between the two, something calls to cut middle layers overlook.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "kumar-2013",
   "slug": "kumar-2013",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/kumar-2013/",
   "label": "Kumar (2013)",
   "title": "Insider action research: premises and promises",
   "year": 2013,
   "journal": "Journal of Organizational Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/09534811311307969",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "other",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Drawing on action research in three Indian Railways manufacturing units, the author argues insider researchers need credibility and constantly tended relationships, and that middle managers suit that role better than top managers.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "edwards-and-gill-2012",
   "slug": "edwards-and-gill-2012",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/edwards-and-gill-2012/",
   "label": "Edwards & Gill (2012)",
   "title": "Transformational leadership across hierarchical levels in UK manufacturing organizations",
   "year": 2012,
   "journal": "Leadership & Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/01437731211193106",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Using 360-degree ratings of 367 managers from 38 UK manufacturers, 215 of them with an agreed hierarchical level, the study found transformational leadership was effective at every level, transactional leadership only lower down, and hands-off leadership nowhere.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "davis-et-al-2012",
   "slug": "davis-et-al-2012",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/davis-et-al-2012/",
   "label": "Davis et al. (2012)",
   "title": "Fostering strategic awareness at an organization's boundary",
   "year": 2012,
   "journal": "Leadership & Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/01437731211229287",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In a survey of tellers and customer service staff at one large regional bank, strategy messages from top and middle managers were tied to frontline strategic awareness in different ways, and the two sources interacted.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "moen-and-federici-2012",
   "slug": "moen-and-federici-2012",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/moen-and-federici-2012/",
   "label": "Moen & Federici (2012)",
   "title": "The Effect of External Executive Coaching and Coaching-Based Leadership on Need Satisfaction.",
   "year": 2012,
   "journal": "Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": null,
   "source_url": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/search?q=The+Effect+of+External+Executive+Coaching+and+Coaching-Based+Leadership+on+Need+Satisfaction",
   "source_url_kind": "search",
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "experiment",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Over a year at a Norwegian company the authors describe as a Fortune 500 high-tech firm, executives given outside coaching reported more satisfied needs at work than uncoached executives, and middle managers in a coaching-based leadership program reported more than uncoached managers, by a smaller margin; the study did not test that difference.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "canales-2013",
   "slug": "canales-2013",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/canales-2013/",
   "label": "Canales (2013)",
   "title": "Constructing Interlocking Rationales in Top‐driven Strategic Renewal",
   "year": 2013,
   "journal": "British Journal of Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8551.2012.00821.x",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In a top-driven renewal, after top managers repositioned the middle level, middle managers built reputation through operational efficiency, then shaped their own strategic role, until top and middle were reinforcing each other's efforts.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "ren-and-guo-2011",
   "slug": "ren-and-guo-2011",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/ren-and-guo-2011/",
   "label": "Ren & Guo (2011)",
   "title": "Middle Managers’ Strategic Role in the Corporate Entrepreneurial Process: Attention-Based Effects",
   "year": 2011,
   "journal": "Journal of Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0149206310397769",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "conceptual",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "The authors propose that middle managers mostly pass upward the new ideas that fit the firm's current strategic focus, and can time their pitches to win top management's attention or even reshape it.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "berg-et-al-2012",
   "slug": "berg-et-al-2012",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/berg-et-al-2012/",
   "label": "Berg et al. (2012)",
   "title": "Changing Leadership and Gender in Public Sector Organizations",
   "year": 2012,
   "journal": "British Journal of Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8551.2011.00751.x",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "conceptual",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Mostly drawing on the literature, plus some findings from Swedish and English higher education and social work, the authors argue new public management goes with masculinist rationality that rewards individual winners and diverts attention from collective gender issues.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "raes-et-al-2011",
   "slug": "raes-et-al-2011",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/raes-et-al-2011/",
   "label": "Raes et al. (2011)",
   "title": "The Interface of the Top Management Team and Middle Managers: A Process Model",
   "year": 2011,
   "journal": "Academy of Management Review",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.2009.0088",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "conceptual",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "The authors propose that how top teams and middle managers interact, including their role behaviors and mutual trust, shapes both the quality of strategic decisions and how well they are carried out.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "wang-et-al-2011",
   "slug": "wang-et-al-2011",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/wang-et-al-2011/",
   "label": "Wang et al. (2011)",
   "title": "CEO leadership behaviors, organizational performance, and employees' attitudes",
   "year": 2011,
   "journal": "The Leadership Quarterly",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.leaqua.2010.12.009",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In 125 Chinese firms, CEOs' task-focused behaviors were linked directly to firm performance, while their relationship-focused behaviors were linked to middle managers' attitudes, which in turn tied to performance.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "bryant-and-stensaker-2011",
   "slug": "bryant-and-stensaker-2011",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/bryant-and-stensaker-2011/",
   "label": "Bryant & Stensaker (2011)",
   "title": "The Competing Roles of Middle Management: Negotiated Order In the Context of Change",
   "year": 2011,
   "journal": "Journal of Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1080/14697017.2011.586951",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "conceptual",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "The authors propose negotiated order as a lens on middle managers juggling competing roles during change, urging study of how they negotiate new ways of working, within themselves, and over how far they can legitimately push.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "smith-et-al-2010",
   "slug": "smith-et-al-2010",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/smith-et-al-2010/",
   "label": "Smith et al. (2010)",
   "title": "Everyday Sensegiving: A Closer Look at Successful Plant Managers",
   "year": 2010,
   "journal": "The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0021886310369932",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Interviews and site visits at 11 plants in nine industries found each successful plant manager actively shaping how employees saw the organization and its values; four central values emerged: people, openness, positivity and community.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "sebora-et-al-2010",
   "slug": "sebora-et-al-2010",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/sebora-et-al-2010/",
   "label": "Sebora et al. (2010)",
   "title": "Corporate entrepreneurship in the face of changing competition",
   "year": 2010,
   "journal": "Journal of Organizational Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/09534811011055421",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "mixed",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In six Thai manufacturing firms, management support, rewards and worker job discretion were tied to internal and financial improvement, while time for idea generation and cross-boundary communication were not significantly tied to corporate entrepreneurship.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "mccabe-2010",
   "slug": "mccabe-2010",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/mccabe-2010/",
   "label": "McCabe (2010)",
   "title": "Taking the long view",
   "year": 2010,
   "journal": "Journal of Organizational Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/09534811011049581",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "During one organization's reengineering, supervisors' memories of how things used to be both helped and hindered change, suggesting a workplace culture cannot simply be wiped clean and rebuilt.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "hui-et-al-2010",
   "slug": "hui-et-al-2010",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/hui-et-al-2010/",
   "label": "Hui et al. (2010)",
   "title": "The moderating effects of polychronicity and achievement striving on the relationship between task variety and organization-based self-esteem of mid-level managers in China",
   "year": 2010,
   "journal": "Human Relations",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0018726709358273",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Among 260 middle managers in three Chinese organizations, those who liked juggling several tasks and were driven to achieve felt most capable and valued at work when their jobs offered more variety.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "cross-2010",
   "slug": "cross-2010",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/cross-2010/",
   "label": "Cross (2010)",
   "title": "Barriers to the executive suite: evidence from Ireland",
   "year": 2010,
   "journal": "Leadership & Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/01437731011024376",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Interviews with 30 women middle managers in Ireland found many felt pressured to stay put rather than seek promotion as career demands collided with family life, and they saw visibility as key to advancing.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "rouleau-and-balogun-2011",
   "slug": "rouleau-and-balogun-2011",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/rouleau-and-balogun-2011/",
   "label": "Rouleau & Balogun (2011)",
   "title": "Middle Managers, Strategic Sensemaking, and Discursive Competence",
   "year": 2011,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-6486.2010.00941.x",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Four vignettes of middle managers at Radio-Canada and a UK engineering multinational illustrate how they moved strategic change by pairing the right words with the right setting, drawing on shared language, symbols and culture to bring people at other levels along.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "hom-et-al-2009",
   "slug": "hom-et-al-2009",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/hom-et-al-2009/",
   "label": "Hom et al. (2009)",
   "title": "Explaining employment relationships with social exchange and job embeddedness.",
   "year": 2009,
   "journal": "Journal of Applied Psychology",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1037/a0013453",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In two surveys of Chinese managers, including 526 middle managers in 41 firms, generous employer investment in staff was linked to lower quit intentions and more commitment, through a sense of exchange and feeling rooted in the job.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "shi-et-al-2009",
   "slug": "shi-et-al-2009",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/shi-et-al-2009/",
   "label": "Shi et al. (2009)",
   "title": "The Role of Middle Management in the Strategy Process: Group Affiliation, Structural Holes, and Tertius Iungens",
   "year": 2009,
   "journal": "Journal of Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0149206309346338",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "conceptual",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "The authors argue that middle managers broker between groups in eight different ways, each serving different strategic goals, and that bridging gaps between unconnected people is not always the smart move.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "karsten-et-al-2009",
   "slug": "karsten-et-al-2009",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/karsten-et-al-2009/",
   "label": "Karsten et al. (2009)",
   "title": "Leadership style and entrepreneurial change",
   "year": 2009,
   "journal": "Journal of Organizational Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/09534810910933915",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "archival",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Philips' 1990s transformation took hold only as it revived existing ideas such as quality management, the authors conclude, and its success partly reflected the historical role those ideas had played in the company.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "taylor-and-helfat-2009",
   "slug": "taylor-and-helfat-2009",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/taylor-and-helfat-2009/",
   "label": "Taylor & Helfat (2009)",
   "title": "Organizational Linkages for Surviving Technological Change: Complementary Assets, Middle Management, and Ambidexterity",
   "year": 2009,
   "journal": "Organization Science",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.1090.0429",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "conceptual",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "IBM and NCR are used to argue that firms survive technology shifts when middle managers link new-tech teams to existing assets.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "vilkinas-et-al-2009",
   "slug": "vilkinas-et-al-2009",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/vilkinas-et-al-2009/",
   "label": "Vilkinas et al. (2009)",
   "title": "Predictors of leadership effectiveness for Chinese managers",
   "year": 2009,
   "journal": "Leadership & Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/01437730910981944",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In 360-degree ratings of 49 Chinese middle managers, they focused most on delivering results and monitoring and least on innovating, rated themselves higher than others did, and developing staff best predicted effectiveness.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "beck-and-plowman-2009",
   "slug": "beck-and-plowman-2009",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/beck-and-plowman-2009/",
   "label": "Beck & Plowman (2009)",
   "title": "Experiencing Rare and Unusual Events Richly: The Role of Middle Managers in Animating and Guiding Organizational Interpretation",
   "year": 2009,
   "journal": "Organization Science",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.1090.0451",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "conceptual",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "The authors propose that middle managers, caught between top and front-line views, can help organizations learn from rare events by first stirring up differing interpretations and later blending them into a richer shared read.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "thompson-et-al-2008",
   "slug": "thompson-et-al-2008",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/thompson-et-al-2008/",
   "label": "Thompson et al. (2008)",
   "title": "A Five Factor Framework for Coaching Middle Managers",
   "year": 2008,
   "journal": "Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": null,
   "source_url": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/search?q=A+Five+Factor+Framework+for+Coaching+Middle+Managers",
   "source_url_kind": "search",
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "conceptual",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "The authors propose a framework that sorts middle managers' work by whom they deal with (top managers, peers or staff) and whether they are sharing information or trying to shape others' views, and report it helps their coaching clients.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "fronda-and-moriceau-2008",
   "slug": "fronda-and-moriceau-2008",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/fronda-and-moriceau-2008/",
   "label": "Fronda & Moriceau (2008)",
   "title": "I am not your hero: change management and culture shocks in a public sector corporation",
   "year": 2008,
   "journal": "Journal of Organizational Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/09534810810903234",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In a telecom takeover, senior leaders who left out middle managers' voices ran into trouble implementing change; the authors argue resistance can be a check on over-optimistic plans.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "wright-2009",
   "slug": "wright-2009",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/wright-2009/",
   "label": "Wright (2009)",
   "title": "Inside Out? Organizational Membership, Ambiguity and the Ambivalent Identity of the Internal Consultant",
   "year": 2009,
   "journal": "British Journal of Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8551.2008.00585.x",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Interviews with HR and organizational development managers working as internal consultants suggest they build an in-between identity, part insider and part outsider, that can be a source of strength as well as strain.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "mcguire-et-al-2008",
   "slug": "mcguire-et-al-2008",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/mcguire-et-al-2008/",
   "label": "McGuire et al. (2008)",
   "title": "The Role of Line Managers as Human Resource Agents in Fostering Organizational Change in Public Services",
   "year": 2008,
   "journal": "Journal of Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1080/14697010801937580",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "conceptual",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "The authors propose a model of what helps and hinders line managers in public services as they take on HR duties, concluding they need adequate support to do it well.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "wooldridge-et-al-2008",
   "slug": "wooldridge-et-al-2008",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/wooldridge-et-al-2008/",
   "label": "Wooldridge et al. (2008)",
   "title": "The Middle Management Perspective on Strategy Process: Contributions, Synthesis, and Future Research",
   "year": 2008,
   "journal": "Journal of Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0149206308324326",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "review/meta-analysis",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "A review of 25 years of strategy research on middle managers organizes a scattered literature into key constructs, relationships and contributions, and charts directions for future work.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "jones-et-al-2008",
   "slug": "jones-et-al-2008",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/jones-et-al-2008/",
   "label": "Jones et al. (2008)",
   "title": "Employee perceptions of organizational change: impact of hierarchical level",
   "year": 2008,
   "journal": "Leadership & Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/01437730810876122",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In a hospital facing downsizing and a move, executives talked more about participation and communication, while supervisors and frontline staff talked more about conflict and division.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "mcmullen-et-al-2009",
   "slug": "mcmullen-et-al-2009",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/mcmullen-et-al-2009/",
   "label": "McMullen et al. (2009)",
   "title": "Managerial (In)attention to Competitive Threats",
   "year": 2009,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-6486.2008.00799.x",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "conceptual",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "This theory paper proposes why middle managers' warnings about emerging rivals can go unheeded: different positions in the firm trigger different motivational focus, which tilts what top managers pay attention to.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "jogulu-and-wood-2008",
   "slug": "jogulu-and-wood-2008",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/jogulu-and-wood-2008/",
   "label": "Jogulu & Wood (2008)",
   "title": "A cross‐cultural study into peer evaluations of women's leadership effectiveness",
   "year": 2008,
   "journal": "Leadership & Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/01437730810906344",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Surveying 324 middle managers in Malaysia and Australia, the authors found women's leadership was rated less effective by peers in Malaysia than in Australia, which they link to cultural beliefs about women's roles.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "bowles-et-al-2007",
   "slug": "bowles-et-al-2007",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/bowles-et-al-2007/",
   "label": "Bowles et al. (2007)",
   "title": "Coaching leaders in middle and executive management: goals, performance, buy‐in",
   "year": 2007,
   "journal": "Leadership & Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/01437730710761715",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "other",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In US Army recruiting, managers given a year of goal-based coaching outperformed more experienced uncoached peers, with the strongest performance gains among middle managers and their teams rather than executives.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "janssen-and-huang-2008",
   "slug": "janssen-and-huang-2008",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/janssen-and-huang-2008/",
   "label": "Janssen & Huang (2008)",
   "title": "Us and Me: Team Identification and Individual Differentiation as Complementary Drivers of Team Members' Citizenship and Creative Behaviors",
   "year": 2008,
   "journal": "Journal of Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0149206307309263",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In a survey of 157 middle-management team members, identifying with the team went with helping teammates, standing out as an individual went with creativity, and through those behaviors both were linked to effectiveness as a team member.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "pappas-and-wooldridge-2007",
   "slug": "pappas-and-wooldridge-2007",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/pappas-and-wooldridge-2007/",
   "label": "Pappas & Wooldridge (2007)",
   "title": "Middle Managers' Divergent Strategic Activity: An Investigation of Multiple Measures of Network Centrality",
   "year": 2007,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-6486.2007.00681.x",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "Among 89 mid-level managers at a U.S. urban hospital, different kinds of network centrality were tied to different parts of strategic renewal, and managers who spanned boundaries were more strategically active.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "bruch-and-walter-2007",
   "slug": "bruch-and-walter-2007",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/bruch-and-walter-2007/",
   "label": "Bruch & Walter (2007)",
   "title": "Leadership in context: investigating hierarchical impacts on transformational leadership",
   "year": 2007,
   "journal": "Leadership & Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/01437730710835452",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "In a Swedish multinational, upper managers showed inspiring, role-model leadership more often than middle managers did, and those behaviors were more strongly tied to their subordinates' job satisfaction.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "rasins-et-al-2007",
   "slug": "rasins-et-al-2007",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/rasins-et-al-2007/",
   "label": "Rasins et al. (2007)",
   "title": "A Systemic Approach to Career Development at McDonald's. ",
   "year": 2007,
   "journal": "Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": null,
   "source_url": "https://www.semanticscholar.org/search?q=A+Systemic+Approach+to+Career+Development+at+McDonald%27s",
   "source_url_kind": "search",
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": null,
   "summary": "McDonald's USA top leadership initiated and sponsored a redesign of middle managers' career paths, with the changes developed by a representative group of those managers; the authors report that over 100 field officers and 3,000 middle managers embraced it.",
   "atlas_version": 1,
   "added": null
  },
  {
   "id": "steffensen-et-al-2019",
   "slug": "steffensen-et-al-2019",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/steffensen-et-al-2019/",
   "label": "Steffensen et al. (2019)",
   "title": "Putting the “Management” Back in Human Resource Management: A Review and Agenda for Future Research",
   "year": 2019,
   "journal": "Journal of Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0149206318816179",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "review/meta-analysis",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "A systematic multilevel review of empirical work on how managers at each level, including lower-to-middle managers, affect HRM content, process and outcomes, ending with a research agenda for each level.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "natarajan-et-al-2019",
   "slug": "natarajan-et-al-2019",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/natarajan-et-al-2019/",
   "label": "Natarajan et al. (2019)",
   "title": "Middle management involvement in resource allocation: The evolution of automated teller machines and bank branches in India",
   "year": 2019,
   "journal": "Strategic Management Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.3017",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "archival",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "In Indian banks, how rewards and monitoring related to resource allocation depended on whether senior or middle managers were more involved in the decisions, suggesting that incentives that work for one level of managers may do less for another.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "gartenberg-et-al-2019",
   "slug": "gartenberg-et-al-2019",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/gartenberg-et-al-2019/",
   "label": "Gartenberg et al. (2019)",
   "title": "Corporate Purpose and Financial Performance",
   "year": 2019,
   "journal": "Organization Science",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.2018.1230",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "Firms whose employees reported both strong purpose and clear direction from management showed higher later performance, and this link was driven by the views of middle managers and professional staff rather than senior executives or hourly workers.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "gjerde-and-alvesson-2019",
   "slug": "gjerde-and-alvesson-2019",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/gjerde-and-alvesson-2019/",
   "label": "Gjerde & Alvesson (2019)",
   "title": "Sandwiched: Exploring role and identity of middle managers in the genuine middle",
   "year": 2019,
   "journal": "Human Relations",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0018726718823243",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "Academic middle managers described acting as 'umbrella carriers', shielding their staff from top-management initiatives and information they saw as unnecessary or harmful, a stance tied to identifying more with their profession and staff than with the managerial role.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "schubert-and-tavassoli-2019",
   "slug": "schubert-and-tavassoli-2019",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/schubert-and-tavassoli-2019/",
   "label": "Schubert & Tavassoli (2019)",
   "title": "Product Innovation and Educational Diversity in Top and Middle Management Teams",
   "year": 2019,
   "journal": "Academy of Management Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2017.0741",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "archival",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "In Swedish firms, educational diversity in top management teams related to whether firms innovated at all, while diversity in middle management teams related to how successful and novel the resulting product innovations were.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "hassard-and-morris-2021",
   "slug": "hassard-and-morris-2021",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/hassard-and-morris-2021/",
   "label": "Hassard & Morris (2021)",
   "title": "The extensification of managerial work in the digital age: Middle managers, spatio-temporal boundaries and control",
   "year": 2021,
   "journal": "Human Relations",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/00187267211003123",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "other",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "Middle managers reported their working time stretching inside the workplace and extending into voluntary work from outside it; the authors link this to lean, agile and reengineering prescriptions and to digital communication tools, and argue that strategic and political choices also shape it.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "dollard-and-bailey-2021",
   "slug": "dollard-and-bailey-2021",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/dollard-and-bailey-2021/",
   "label": "Dollard & Bailey (2021)",
   "title": "Building psychosocial safety climate in turbulent times: The case of COVID-19.",
   "year": 2021,
   "journal": "Journal of Applied Psychology",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1037/apl0000939",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "experiment",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Training middle managers to enact psychosocial safety climate raised that climate in their work units within four months compared with matched control units; after COVID-19 hit, climate stayed higher in the trained units, but communication and commitment rose in both groups as a strong top-management response lifted the control units too.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "splitter-et-al-2021",
   "slug": "splitter-et-al-2021",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/splitter-et-al-2021/",
   "label": "Splitter et al. (2021)",
   "title": "Middle Managers' Struggle Over Their Subject Position in Open Strategy Processes",
   "year": 2021,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.12776",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "When a company opened strategy making to front-line employees, middle managers' traditional role as strategists was undermined, and they took different routes to reclaim it over time.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "kim-et-al-2021",
   "slug": "kim-et-al-2021",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/kim-et-al-2021/",
   "label": "Kim et al. (2021)",
   "title": "When CEOs are all about themselves: Perceived CEO narcissism and middle managers’ workplace behaviors amid the COVID-19 pandemic.",
   "year": 2021,
   "journal": "Journal of Applied Psychology",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1037/apl0000965",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "Middle managers who saw their CEO as narcissistic reported more uncertainty, especially when COVID-19 threatened the firm, and that uncertainty went with more laissez-faire leadership and impression management; an online experiment with working adults supported the model.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "lauche-and-erez-2022",
   "slug": "lauche-and-erez-2022",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/lauche-and-erez-2022/",
   "label": "Lauche & Erez (2022)",
   "title": "The Relational Dynamics of Issue-Selling: Enacting Different Genres for Dealing with Discontent",
   "year": 2022,
   "journal": "Academy of Management Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2020.1484",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Middle managers' discontent could energize, not only inhibit, upward issue selling for strategic renewal, especially when sellers and recipients took each other's perspective; the exchanges took three forms: productive confrontation, avoiding escalation and collective moaning.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "hubel-2022",
   "slug": "hubel-2022",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/hubel-2022/",
   "label": "Hübel (2022)",
   "title": "Entrepreneurship-driven organizational transformation for sustainability: a sensemaking lens",
   "year": 2022,
   "journal": "Journal of Organizational Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/jocm-03-2021-0067",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "In a meat company's shift toward sustainability, increasingly shared sensemaking between top and middle managers, with their involvement differing over time, helped speed and direct the transformation.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "wilden-et-al-2022",
   "slug": "wilden-et-al-2022",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/wilden-et-al-2022/",
   "label": "Wilden et al. (2022)",
   "title": "Selecting Innovation Projects: Do Middle and Senior Managers Differ When It Comes to Radical Innovation?",
   "year": 2022,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.12874",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "experiment",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "Middle and senior managers chose innovation projects differently, especially radical ones: middle managers weighed internal resources such as social capital and know-how, while senior managers focused on external knowledge.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "van-doorn-et-al-2022",
   "slug": "van-doorn-et-al-2022",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/van-doorn-et-al-2022/",
   "label": "Van Doorn et al. (2022)",
   "title": "Opportunity or Threat? Exploring Middle Manager Roles in the Face of Digital Transformation",
   "year": 2022,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.12880",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Automation alone was not significantly related to middle managers' strategic involvement; the link depended on which tasks were automated and on position tenure, with reporting automation going with more involvement for short-tenured managers and budgeting automation going with less for short-tenured but more for long-tenured managers.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "greven-et-al-2022",
   "slug": "greven-et-al-2022",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/greven-et-al-2022/",
   "label": "Greven et al. (2022)",
   "title": "Achieving Product Ambidexterity in New Product Development: The Role of Middle Managers' Dynamic Managerial Capabilities",
   "year": 2022,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.12886",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "Middle managers' specialized education, managerial ties and trust were linked to more product ambidexterity, while solidarity was linked to less.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "azambuja-et-al-2022",
   "slug": "azambuja-et-al-2022",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/azambuja-et-al-2022/",
   "label": "Azambuja et al. (2022)",
   "title": "Walling in and Walling out: Middle Managers' Boundary Work",
   "year": 2022,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.12844",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "Middle managers in a Brazilian audit firm actively built and adjusted internal boundaries, sometimes blocking and sometimes enabling crossing, using four kinds of boundary work.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "porck-and-van-knippenberg-2022",
   "slug": "porck-and-van-knippenberg-2022",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/porck-and-van-knippenberg-2022/",
   "label": "Porck & van Knippenberg (2022)",
   "title": "An Integrative Model of the Role of Structural, Behavioural, and Cognitive Coordination in Intergroup Effectiveness: How Middle Managers Play a Role",
   "year": 2022,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.12841",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "Middle managers' boundary spanning and shared understanding of strategy between teams could substitute for structural coordination, and the two strengthened each other's association with how well interdependent teams performed together, in multisource data on 188 intergroup dyads.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "gerpott-and-van-quaquebeke-2022",
   "slug": "gerpott-and-van-quaquebeke-2022",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/gerpott-and-van-quaquebeke-2022/",
   "label": "Gerpott & Van Quaquebeke (2022)",
   "title": "Kiss‐Up‐Kick‐Down to Get Ahead: A Resource Perspective on How, When, Why, and With Whom Middle Managers Use Ingratiatory and Exploitative Behaviours to Advance Their Careers",
   "year": 2022,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.12855",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "conceptual",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "A conceptual framework for when and how middle managers ingratiate upward and exploit downward to advance their careers, with diminishing returns over time.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "tarakci-et-al-2023",
   "slug": "tarakci-et-al-2023",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/tarakci-et-al-2023/",
   "label": "Tarakci et al. (2023)",
   "title": "Heroes or Villains? Recasting Middle Management Roles, Processes, and Behaviours",
   "year": 2023,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.12989",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "review/meta-analysis",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "An introduction that reviews middle management research and organizes it around roles, coordination processes and agentic behaviours, noting how new ways of organizing and technology are reshaping each.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "zhang-2023",
   "slug": "zhang-2023",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/zhang-2023/",
   "label": "Zhang (2023)",
   "title": "The Changing Role of Managers",
   "year": 2023,
   "journal": "American Journal of Sociology",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1086/727145",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "archival",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "Expectations of managers shifted toward collaboration and away from supervision, especially in innovation-focused firms, and firms treating managers as collaborators had a larger share of middle managers.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "azambuja-and-islam-2023",
   "slug": "azambuja-and-islam-2023",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/azambuja-and-islam-2023/",
   "label": "Azambuja & Islam (2023)",
   "title": "Middle‐Managerial Deviance as a Response to Structural Strain: Rescoping, Reconfiguring and Replacing Norms",
   "year": 2023,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.12911",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "Middle managers deviated from norms when organizational rules clashed with on-the-ground work; their deviance could adapt or replace norms and fed into new norm formation while expanding their own power.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "gong-et-al-2023",
   "slug": "gong-et-al-2023",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/gong-et-al-2023/",
   "label": "Gong et al. (2023)",
   "title": "The Fire to Inspire: A Multilevel and Multimethod Investigation of How and When CEO Passion for Organizational Development Impacts Employee Creativity",
   "year": 2023,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.13019",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "A CEO's passion for developing the company was linked to middle managers showing more transformational leadership, which in turn was linked to frontline employees' creativity.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "letierce-et-al-2023",
   "slug": "letierce-et-al-2023",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/letierce-et-al-2023/",
   "label": "Letierce et al. (2023)",
   "title": "Empowering middle managers to free their strategic capabilities",
   "year": 2023,
   "journal": "Journal of Organizational Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/jocm-02-2022-0044",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Middle managers freed from administrative work and backed by structure and top management adapted the prescribed strategy to local conditions and empowered their front-line teams.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "jaser-2024",
   "slug": "jaser-2024",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/jaser-2024/",
   "label": "Jaser (2024)",
   "title": "Voice Work, Upward Influence during Change ‘When Time is of the Essence’",
   "year": 2024,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.13054",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "When time was short, middle and lower managers passed problems up through relational, reflexive and skip-level moves; skip-level voice by lower managers could strengthen or destabilize middle managers.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "reimers-2024",
   "slug": "reimers-2024",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/reimers-2024/",
   "label": "Reimers (2024)",
   "title": "How Situated Attentions Affect the Choices of Professional Service Managers in the Transition to Hybrid Work Arrangements",
   "year": 2024,
   "journal": "The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/00218863241298712",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Managers' choices about keeping hybrid work or returning to old practices were shaped by what their local context and pressures drew their limited attention to.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "wang-et-al-2024",
   "slug": "wang-et-al-2024",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/wang-et-al-2024/",
   "label": "Wang et al. (2024)",
   "title": "Middle Managers’ Role Overload, Workplace Anxiety, and Resistance to Change: The Moderating Effect of Emotion Regulation Strategies",
   "year": 2024,
   "journal": "The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/00218863241246284",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Middle managers who reported more role overload also reported more resistance to change, and workplace anxiety helped explain the link; their emotion regulation strategies changed how strongly overload was tied to anxiety.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "re-et-al-2024",
   "slug": "re-et-al-2024",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/re-et-al-2024/",
   "label": "Re et al. (2024)",
   "title": "Navigating organizational change through a processual perspective on the transition toward the circular economy: Save The Duck case study",
   "year": 2024,
   "journal": "Journal of Organizational Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/jocm-05-2024-0248",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "In a fashion firm's shift toward a circular economy, involving top and middle management in decisions was a driver of change, while structural adaptation, reluctant mindsets and divergent ideas were sources of resistance.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "gjerde-and-alvesson-2024",
   "slug": "gjerde-and-alvesson-2024",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/gjerde-and-alvesson-2024/",
   "label": "Gjerde & Alvesson (2024)",
   "title": "Living the Janus Face: The Promise and Perils of Role‐Distancing for Middle Managers",
   "year": 2024,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.13041",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "Role distancing at first helped an academic middle manager perform the role without becoming 'a manager', but became a problem of its own once the backstage audience also became a frontstage.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "birollo-et-al-2024",
   "slug": "birollo-et-al-2024",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/birollo-et-al-2024/",
   "label": "Birollo et al. (2024)",
   "title": "Middle Managers’ Relational Dynamics in the Context of Acquisitions: Balancing Strategic Interdependence and Organizational Autonomy",
   "year": 2024,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.13067",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "During acquisitions, middle managers on both sides developed, to varying degrees, an ability to take the other side into account while doing integration work, built up across stages of the deal.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "franck-et-al-2025",
   "slug": "franck-et-al-2025",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/franck-et-al-2025/",
   "label": "Franck et al. (2025)",
   "title": "Middle Managers’ Regulation of the Emotions of Others in Strategy Implementation: A Process Perspective",
   "year": 2025,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.70027",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Middle managers handled their teams' negative emotions about top-down strategy in meetings through a sequence: understanding emotions, tuning in, then encouraging reappraisal.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "li-and-makino-2025",
   "slug": "li-and-makino-2025",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/li-and-makino-2025/",
   "label": "Li & Makino (2025)",
   "title": "Turning Fear Into a Weapon for Change in Response to Threats: A Partnership Approach",
   "year": 2025,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Inquiry",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/10564926251353729",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Fear pushed middle managers both toward inertia and toward change; treating them as partners, with independence from assessment, in decision making and from structural constraints, reduced rigidity by reshaping those fears.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "shaba-2025",
   "slug": "shaba-2025",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/shaba-2025/",
   "label": "Shaba (2025)",
   "title": "Exclusive reliance on videoconferencing technology affordances and its implications for emotion management during organizational change",
   "year": 2025,
   "journal": "Journal of Organizational Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/jocm-09-2024-0559",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Relying only on videoconferencing was experienced as an obstacle to middle managers reading and responding to emotions in time during change, with implications for their ability to help others reappraise change events positively.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "alao-et-al-2026",
   "slug": "alao-et-al-2026",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/alao-et-al-2026/",
   "label": "Alao et al. (2026)",
   "title": "Navigating Resource Tensions During Diversification in Ecosystems: Strategic Leadership Across Organizational Levels",
   "year": 2026,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.70126",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Middle managers resolved commensalistic resource tensions through peer-level deals that let several initiatives share ecosystem resources, while rivalrous tensions drew in senior managers, who either restricted an initiative's access or, working with middle managers, kept resources shared across initiatives.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "randhawa-et-al-2026",
   "slug": "randhawa-et-al-2026",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/randhawa-et-al-2026/",
   "label": "Randhawa et al. (2026)",
   "title": "Middle Managers' Interface Work: Exploring Micro‐Practices for Co‐Adoption of Emerging Ecosystem Value Propositions",
   "year": 2026,
   "journal": "Journal of Management Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/joms.70124",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "Middle managers helped stakeholders co-adopt a new ecosystem value proposition through discursive, relational and material practices, integrated within each interface and aligned across interfaces.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "king-et-al-2019",
   "slug": "king-et-al-2019",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/king-et-al-2019/",
   "label": "King et al. (2019)",
   "title": "What, when, and who: Manager involvement in predicting employee resistance to acquisition integration",
   "year": 2019,
   "journal": "Human Resource Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/hrm.21973",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P4",
     "part_name": "Review on a rhythm, then hold the pace",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "In a cross-sectional survey of 108 managers, mostly middle managers, at Chinese acquirers, more middle-manager involvement in slower integration of the people side went with less employee resistance. The paper's results on the speed of integrating tasks read differently in its abstract and in its results section.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "harris-and-ogbonna-2019",
   "slug": "harris-and-ogbonna-2019",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/harris-and-ogbonna-2019/",
   "label": "Harris & Ogbonna (2019)",
   "title": "Middle Managers’ Work in Recession and Austerity: A Longitudinal Study",
   "year": 2019,
   "journal": "British Journal of Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8551.12360",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "other",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Middle managers' early responses to recession and austerity were largely positive but turned to disillusionment and cynicism as they came to believe superiors used austerity as cover for changes that hurt them and their staff.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "woiceshyn-et-al-2019",
   "slug": "woiceshyn-et-al-2019",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/woiceshyn-et-al-2019/",
   "label": "Woiceshyn et al. (2019)",
   "title": "Microdynamics of Implementing Planned Change on Organizations’ Front Line",
   "year": 2019,
   "journal": "Journal of Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1080/14697017.2019.1602553",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Hospital units implemented planned change better or worse depending on day-to-day activities and interactions between unit managers and nursing staff, which set off virtuous or vicious change cycles.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "gibson-and-groom-2020",
   "slug": "gibson-and-groom-2020",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/gibson-and-groom-2020/",
   "label": "Gibson & Groom (2020)",
   "title": "Understanding ‘Vulnerability’ and ‘Political Skill’ in Academy Middle Management During Organisational Change in Professional Youth Football",
   "year": 2020,
   "journal": "Journal of Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1080/14697017.2020.1819860",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "A newly appointed football academy manager handled the ambiguity and job vulnerability of change by managing up, down and across through skilled micro-politics and trust building.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "mikkola-and-stormi-2020",
   "slug": "mikkola-and-stormi-2020",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/mikkola-and-stormi-2020/",
   "label": "Mikkola & Stormi (2020)",
   "title": "Change Talk in Hospital Management Groups",
   "year": 2020,
   "journal": "Journal of Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1080/14697017.2020.1775679",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "In hospital middle management meetings, talk about change took forms of collaboration, control and confrontation, with positioning shaping power relations in the change.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "salasvallina-et-al-2020",
   "slug": "salasvallina-et-al-2020",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/salasvallina-et-al-2020/",
   "label": "Salas‐Vallina et al. (2020)",
   "title": "The challenge of increasing employees' well‐being and performance: How human resource management practices and engaging leadership work together toward reaching this goal",
   "year": 2020,
   "journal": "Human Resource Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/hrm.22021",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "Middle managers' engaging leadership went with more genuine implementation of well-being-oriented HRM and was directly linked to employee performance.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "outila-et-al-2020",
   "slug": "outila-et-al-2020",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/outila-et-al-2020/",
   "label": "Outila et al. (2020)",
   "title": "“Trust But Verify”: How middle managers in a multinational use proverbs to translate an imported management concept",
   "year": 2020,
   "journal": "Organization Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0170840620934065",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P2",
     "part_name": "Make sense together, top included",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Middle managers in a Russian subsidiary used proverbs to reconcile an imported 'western' empowerment concept with local ideals of good management, acting as both translators and implementers.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "toegel-et-al-2021",
   "slug": "toegel-et-al-2021",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/toegel-et-al-2021/",
   "label": "Toegel et al. (2021)",
   "title": "Secrecy in Practice: How Middle Managers Promote Strategic Initiatives behind the Scenes",
   "year": 2021,
   "journal": "Organization Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0170840621998563",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Middle managers used secrecy under unfavourable conditions to build support for initiatives; handled carefully it increased receptivity, mishandled it bred resistance and distrust.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "larsson-and-holmberg-2021",
   "slug": "larsson-and-holmberg-2021",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/larsson-and-holmberg-2021/",
   "label": "Larsson & Holmberg (2021)",
   "title": "Taming the Survey: Managing the Employee Survey to Create Space for Change Oriented Leadership",
   "year": 2021,
   "journal": "Journal of Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1080/14697017.2021.1941192",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Middle managers reinterpreted, prioritized and embedded a standardized employee survey to create space for local change, and the authors suggest their considerable effort was a critical factor in making the survey useful.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "van-dam-et-al-2021",
   "slug": "van-dam-et-al-2021",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/van-dam-et-al-2021/",
   "label": "van Dam et al. (2021)",
   "title": "The Impact of Middle Managers on Employees’ Responses to a Merger: An LMX and Appraisal Theory Approach",
   "year": 2021,
   "journal": "Journal of Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1080/14697017.2021.1888772",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P1",
     "part_name": "Surface both ways",
     "verdict": "supports"
    },
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Employees with better relationships with their manager reported more change information and chances to participate, felt more positively about the merger, and were more open to it.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "van-niekerk-and-jansen-van-rensburg-2022",
   "slug": "van-niekerk-and-jansen-van-rensburg-2022",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/van-niekerk-and-jansen-van-rensburg-2022/",
   "label": "Van Niekerk & Jansen van Rensburg (2022)",
   "title": "Middle Managers’ Strategising Practices to Effect Strategic Change",
   "year": 2022,
   "journal": "Journal of Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1080/14697017.2022.2040572",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Professional middle managers in a restructuring university used six strategising practices, shaped by cognitive and emotional experience as both implementers and recipients of change.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "joo-et-al-2022",
   "slug": "joo-et-al-2022",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/joo-et-al-2022/",
   "label": "Joo et al. (2022)",
   "title": "Gender diversity advantage at middle management: Implications for high performance work system improvement and organizational performance",
   "year": 2022,
   "journal": "Human Resource Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/hrm.22159",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "archival",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "Greater gender diversity among middle managers was linked to better HPWS improvement and profitability, but only where subordinates were also gender diverse.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "alshwayat-2023",
   "slug": "alshwayat-2023",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/alshwayat-2023/",
   "label": "Alshwayat (2023)",
   "title": "Innovation and Change from A Multi-level Paradoxical Perspective in a Highly Formalized Organization",
   "year": 2023,
   "journal": "Journal of Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1080/14697017.2023.2234391",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "In a highly formalized bank, middle managers split between those valuing change and those preferring traditional methods, and contradictions across levels held change back.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "christie-and-tippmann-2023",
   "slug": "christie-and-tippmann-2023",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/christie-and-tippmann-2023/",
   "label": "Christie & Tippmann (2023)",
   "title": "Intended or unintended strategy? The activities of middle managers in strategy implementation",
   "year": 2023,
   "journal": "Long Range Planning",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lrp.2023.102410",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Seven of ten middle-manager implementation activities occurred at different frequencies when strategies came out as intended versus unintended.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "fernandezmesa-et-al-2023",
   "slug": "fernandezmesa-et-al-2023",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/fernandezmesa-et-al-2023/",
   "label": "Fernández‐Mesa et al. (2023)",
   "title": "Knowledge network structure and middle management involvement as determinants of TMT members’ ambidexterity: A multilevel analysis",
   "year": 2023,
   "journal": "Long Range Planning",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lrp.2023.102318",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "mixed",
   "grade": "low",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "Among 123 top team members in 20 public hospitals, leaders' network centrality and top team network density were associated with members' ability to balance exploration and exploitation; the paper frames middle management involvement in decisions as supporting that ability.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "hsu-and-chen-2023",
   "slug": "hsu-and-chen-2023",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/hsu-and-chen-2023/",
   "label": "Hsu & Chen (2023)",
   "title": "Top and middle management characteristics and internationalization speed",
   "year": 2023,
   "journal": "Leadership & Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/lodj-04-2022-0176",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "archival",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "Output-oriented top teams were linked to faster internationalization, and middle management teams similar to the top team in background and international experience seemed to support that speed.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "usman-et-al-2023",
   "slug": "usman-et-al-2023",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/usman-et-al-2023/",
   "label": "Usman et al. (2023)",
   "title": "Servant Leadership as a Catalyst for Middle Managers’ Learning Ambidexterity: A Resource‐Based Perspective",
   "year": 2023,
   "journal": "British Journal of Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8551.12761",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "Servant leadership from their supervisors was linked to middle managers' exploratory and exploitative learning through structural empowerment and self-efficacy, more so when supervisors spanned boundaries.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "supriharyanti-et-al-2024",
   "slug": "supriharyanti-et-al-2024",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/supriharyanti-et-al-2024/",
   "label": "Supriharyanti et al. (2024)",
   "title": "Empowering leadership and team change capability: the mediating effect of team PsyCap",
   "year": 2024,
   "journal": "Leadership & Organization Development Journal",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1108/lodj-07-2022-0331",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "survey",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Middle managers' empowering leadership was linked to team psychological capital, which carried the link to teams' learning capability for change but not to their process or context capability.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "sasaki-et-al-2024",
   "slug": "sasaki-et-al-2024",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/sasaki-et-al-2024/",
   "label": "Sasaki et al. (2024)",
   "title": "When Top Managers’ Temporal Orientations Collide: Middle managers and the strategic use of the past",
   "year": 2024,
   "journal": "Organization Studies",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1177/01708406241236604",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative case",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "When top managers disagreed about the past and future, middle managers gradually took a central role in using the firm's history, and could shift the time orientations of those above and below them.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "koivunen-et-al-2024",
   "slug": "koivunen-et-al-2024",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/koivunen-et-al-2024/",
   "label": "Koivunen et al. (2024)",
   "title": "How Managers Experience Downsizing: Navigating among Professional, Loyal, Empathic, and Critical Positions",
   "year": 2024,
   "journal": "Journal of Change Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1080/14697017.2024.2426804",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Managers carrying out a downsizing moved between professional, loyal, empathic and critical positions, struggling to meet conflicting expectations from top management and subordinates.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "esper-et-al-2025",
   "slug": "esper-et-al-2025",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/esper-et-al-2025/",
   "label": "Esper et al. (2025)",
   "title": "Between Strategy and Reality: Middle Managers’ Responses to CSR Decoupling",
   "year": 2025,
   "journal": "British Journal of Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8551.70030",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "mixed",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P6",
     "part_name": "The middle's own weather",
     "verdict": "supports"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Middle managers judged all kinds of CSR decoupling negatively, were most likely to act when peers caused it, and leaned toward resigning when top managers caused it because of the emotional toll.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "tenhiala-et-al-2025",
   "slug": "tenhiala-et-al-2025",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/tenhiala-et-al-2025/",
   "label": "Tenhiälä et al. (2025)",
   "title": "Between Consistency and Adaptation: How Middle Managers Shape Compensation System Implementation",
   "year": 2025,
   "journal": "Human Resource Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1002/hrm.70043",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "mixed",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [
    {
     "part": "P3",
     "part_name": "Start it close to the work",
     "verdict": "mixed"
    }
   ],
   "about_change": true,
   "summary": "Middle managers and employees blamed compensation-system problems on different causes; how much managers identified with the system and felt agency explained whether they championed, complied, adapted or resigned.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  },
  {
   "id": "reeves-and-rigg-2026",
   "slug": "reeves-and-rigg-2026",
   "url": "https://unfreeze.us/atlas/studies/reeves-and-rigg-2026/",
   "label": "Reeves & Rigg (2026)",
   "title": "‘If I Don't Get That Belonging Among Us It All Falls Down’: How Middle Managers Experience Belonging Through Self and Others",
   "year": 2026,
   "journal": "British Journal of Management",
   "doi": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8551.70110",
   "source_url": null,
   "source_url_kind": null,
   "kind": "study",
   "design": "qualitative interviews",
   "grade": "medium",
   "loop": [],
   "about_change": false,
   "summary": "Middle managers judged their own belonging partly through whether the people they manage seemed to belong.",
   "atlas_version": 2,
   "added": "2026-10-30"
  }
 ]
}
