Home / Books / Leading Change by John Kotter: What the Research Shows
Book review
Leading Change by John Kotter: What the Research Shows
Leading Change is John Kotter's 1996 book on why large organizational changes fail and how leaders can avoid it. It is widely read, and the research testing it is thinner than its reputation suggests.
By Gabriel Lopez · Updated October 13, 2026 · Every source is listed at the end
What the book is
Leading Change is a book by John P. Kotter. Harvard Business School Press published it in Boston in 1996; a library catalog lists 187 numbered pages plus front matter (Kotter, 1996). Harvard Business Review Press published Leading Change, With a New Preface by the Author in October 2012, with the preface dated November 2012 (Kotter, 2012). The O'Reilly listing for the new edition does not mention the 1996 original, and the sources I checked do not describe changes to the text beyond the preface.
The book shares its main title with Kotter's 1995 Harvard Business Review article, Leading Change: Why Transformation Efforts Fail (Kotter, 1995). The two are related but are not the same document.
Where it came from
The article came first. In it, Kotter reported that he had watched more than 100 companies try to become stronger competitors over about ten years. The efforts went by names such as total quality management, reengineering, rightsizing, restructuring, cultural change and turnarounds. A few succeeded strongly, a few failed, and most landed in between, closer to the disappointing end (Kotter, 1995).
He drew two lessons. Transformation moves through several phases that usually take a long time, and skipping steps gives an appearance of speed without lasting results. And a serious mistake in any phase can do real damage and erase earlier gains. He added that even capable managers often make at least one major error (Kotter, 1995).
According to the abstract of a later review, the book was based on his personal business and research experience, and it did not draw on outside sources that questioned its value (Appelbaum et al., 2012). That is the reason the research test below matters. The model started as one careful observer's reading of what he saw, not as the result of a controlled study.
What it argues
In my words, the argument is that large changes move through phases that take a long time, that skipping phases gives only the look of speed, and that one serious mistake can erase earlier gains (Kotter, 1995). The description on the 2012 edition's listing says the book sets out an eight-step process, identifies where even strong performers go wrong, and offers practical tools for leaders (Kotter, 2012).
I will not list the steps here. That description summarizes them only as an eight-step process, and the book is the place to read them in Kotter's own order. The practical idea is that a leader should expect a change to need sustained effort across phases, not a single launch.
Why it spread
The listing for the 2012 edition calls the book an international bestseller and says millions have read Kotter's ideas. Those are marketing claims; I have not found an independent count.
A reviewer team offered a simpler explanation for the model's popularity. In the abstract of their review, they concluded that it appears to owe its popularity more to a direct and usable format than to any scientific consensus about the results (Appelbaum et al., 2012). In my view that is also its practical strength: a manager can pick it up, find the stage a change has reached, and ask what has been skipped.
In the Unfrozen Research Index (24,443 abstracts of research articles and reviews supplied by OpenAlex, covering 28 of the 29 journals (21 core, 7 expansion), 2007 to 2026, 2026 to date), 9 titles or abstracts mention Kotter. That is a keyword count of titles and abstracts, not of full texts, and a study can use his model without naming him in the abstract, so the true figure is higher. The nine include a Spanish-language version of his 1995 article in Harvard Business Review and an article, first published online in 2022 in the Journal of Change Management, that critiques one step of the model. I read the small number as a hint, not a finding, that the model is named more often in practice than in these journals' abstracts.
What the research shows
The most direct test is a review by Appelbaum, Habashy, Malo and Shafiq (2012), published in the Journal of Management Development; what follows is from its published abstract. They collected arguments and counterarguments from about 15 years of literature on each of the eight steps. They found support for most of the steps. They found no formal studies covering the whole model and its structure. They found no evidence against the model, and they concluded that it remains a recommendable reference. They also noted several limitations, and suggested that it works best as an implementation planning tool, with complementary tools to handle context and obstacles (Appelbaum et al., 2012).
Read plainly, that is a modest endorsement. Most of the individual steps have some support in the literature. The claim that these eight steps, in this order, are what produces success has not been tested as a package.
There is also a specific critique of the first step. In their article's abstract, McLaren, van der Hoorn and Fein (2023) argued that building urgency by persuading employees that the status quo is more dangerous than the future is adversarial, can heighten anxiety, and works against the well-documented human preference for existing conditions. They proposed emphasizing the importance of the future state instead. That is one paper's argument, and it needs further testing, but it shows that the model is still being examined at the level of its parts.
The anxiety point connects to a larger body of work on how people react when a change reaches them; see resistance to change.
Using it without over-trusting it
The reviewers' own advice is a good guide. They suggested treating the model as a tool for planning an implementation, and using other tools alongside it to adapt to context and obstacles (Appelbaum et al., 2012). They also called for studies of the model as a whole, and for change researchers to link more closely with the people who use their work, so that findings reach practitioners in a usable form.
For a manager, that translates into a few plain habits. Before a change starts, write down how long you expect it to take and who has to keep pushing for that long. Midway, check whether any early phase was skipped to save time, since skipping phases is the mistake the 1995 article warns about. And when a step does not seem to fit your situation, treat that as information about your organization, not as proof that you are doing it wrong.
A balanced verdict
Read it for a clear sense of how long transformation takes and for a set of questions to ask when a change stalls. The model is easy to use, and the review of the literature found nothing that contradicts it.
Do not read it as a proven method. The whole-model evidence is missing, the original basis was one author's experience, and at least one step has been challenged on research grounds. Use it as a planning aid and test its assumptions against what you see in your own organization. The Kotter entry covers the model in more detail, and the list of change management books places it next to books with a stronger research base.
Common questions
Who wrote Leading Change and when?
John P. Kotter wrote it. Harvard Business School Press published the book in 1996, and Harvard Business Review Press issued a new edition with a new preface in 2012. It shares its main title with his 1995 Harvard Business Review article, Leading Change: Why Transformation Efforts Fail.
What is the Leading Change book about?
It argues that large organizational changes move through several phases that take time, and that a serious mistake in any phase can undo earlier progress. The description of the 2012 edition calls it an eight-step process for managing change.
Is Kotter's Leading Change model backed by research?
Partly. A 2012 review reports finding support for most of the individual steps in the wider literature, but no formal study of the model as a whole. It found no evidence against the model.
Is the 2012 edition different from the 1996 book?
The 2012 edition carries a new preface by the author. The sources I checked do not describe any other change to the text.
Related
Sources
- Kotter, J. P. (1996). Leading Change. Harvard Business School Press. Library catalog record: https://catalog.yln.info/Record/a364254
- Kotter, J. P. (2012). Leading Change, With a New Preface by the Author. Harvard Business Review Press. https://www.oreilly.com/library/view/-/9781422186442/ (summary read)
- Kotter, J. P. (1995). Leading change: Why transformation efforts fail. Harvard Business Review, March-April 1995. https://hbr.org/1995/03/leading-change-why-transformation-efforts-fail-2
- Appelbaum, S. H., Habashy, S., Malo, J.-L., & Shafiq, H. (2012). Back to the future: Revisiting Kotter's 1996 change model. Journal of Management Development, 31(8), 764-782. https://doi.org/10.1108/02621711211253231 (abstract read)
- McLaren, T. A. S., van der Hoorn, B., & Fein, E. C. (2023). Why vilifying the status quo can derail a change effort: Kotter's contradiction, and theory adaptation. Journal of Change Management, 23(1), 93-111. https://doi.org/10.1080/14697017.2022.2137835 (abstract read)