Conversation kit · Free

Surface: a conversation kit

The Unfrozen Loop · Surface both ways

What this part means

Bad news and good ideas should travel up as easily as plans travel down.

When problems stop at your level, the people above you make decisions on a picture that's already out of date.

What to say to your team this week

"We're partway into this change, and I don't think I'm hearing everything that's going wrong. That's on me, not you.

This week I want the problems: what's slowing you down, what doesn't work the way the plan says, what we're working around. I'll take them up the line as you said them, without polishing them, and I'll tell you what came back."

Three questions to ask

  1. What's getting in the way of this change right now?
  2. What have you stopped mentioning because nothing happened the last time?
  3. If you could tell the people who planned this one thing, what would it be?

What to listen for

Signs it's working

  • People name specific problems, not just "it's fine."
  • Someone raises a problem you didn't already know about.
  • People ask what happened to the last thing they raised.

Signs it's stuck

  • The room goes quiet, or everyone says it's going well.
  • Problems reach you through side conversations, not the meeting.
  • You catch yourself softening what you heard before passing it on.

What to send up to your leader

One short message. Copy it, fill in the brackets, send it.

Quick update on [the change]. My team raised three problems this week, as they said them: [1], [2], [3]. The one I'd look at first is [1], because [reason]. Could you tell me by [day] what happens with it? They'll ask, and I'd like to have an answer to give them.

The study behind it

In English hospital care for older people, nurse middle managers could pass knowledge down to fellow nurses but struggled to pass it up the hierarchy or across to doctors. The authors warn that without support from HR, the chain of information can break instead of carrying it through. It's one qualitative study of three English hospitals.

Currie, Burgess & Hayton (2015), Human Resource Management. Read the study summary in the Atlas. Evidence strength in the Atlas: Medium.

Try it with your team

Run the Middle is a free game with an invented company. Your team plays the VP leading a change through the managers in the middle, votes on each decision, and sees where the change stalls.

Open a team room

The Unfrozen Loop is a working model built from published studies, not a validated instrument. The script, questions and signs are practice suggestions, not tested methods. Not an assessment.

Unfrozen conversation kit · unfreeze.us/kits/surface/ · A working model. Not an assessment.