Home / OD Encyclopedia / Change management models compared: seven models and the evidence for each

OD Encyclopedia · Comparison

Change management models compared: seven models and the evidence for each

These seven change models answer different questions, about groups, leaders, individuals, transitions, emotions or organizational fit. In the sources reviewed for this page, none has been tested as a whole against an alternative in a controlled study. Choose one for the problem in front of you, and know how much weight it can bear.

By Gabriel Lopez · Updated October 26, 2026 · Every source is listed at the end

In brief

Lewin is useful for thinking about established group practices, Kotter for coordinating collective change, and ADKAR for examining individual adoption. Bridges focuses on the psychological adjustment that accompanies an external change. McKinsey 7-S helps investigate whether organizational arrangements fit together. The Kübler-Ross change curve borrows grief stages to describe emotional reactions. The Unfrozen Loop, my own model, focuses on the managers in the middle who carry a change. These are different purposes, so choosing a model starts with identifying the problem; the evidence discussed below does not support a universal ranking.

Evidence levels

To compare models fairly, this page sorts them by the strongest kind of evidence found for each in the sources reviewed. The levels describe the evidence, not how useful a model is in a meeting.

Level 1 · Tested as a whole against an alternative

None of the seven, in the sources reviewed

Level 2 · Built from controlled studies of related practices; model itself untested

Unfrozen Loop

Level 3 · Applied, reviewed or studied in real settings; no controlled test of the model

Kotter Lewin ADKAR McKinsey 7-S Bridges

Level 4 · Borrowed from another field, contested there, untested for workplaces

Kübler-Ross change curve

Within Level 3 the depth varies a great deal. Kotter has a literature review of its steps and many applications. Among the sources reviewed, Bridges has one small exploratory study. The Loop sits at Level 2 because each of its parts cites controlled studies of related practices, not because the Loop has been tested; it is my model, so read its placement with that in mind.

Side by side

Model Creator and timing Main focus Steps or elements Evidence level Main limitation
Lewin Kurt Lewin, 1947; origin of the familiar three-step formulation is debated (Cummings et al., 2016; Burnes, 2020) Group behavior and the conditions sustaining it Common shorthand: unfreeze, change, refreeze; original wording differs 3 A linear or static reading is contested by defenders of the broader approach (Burnes, 2004, 2020)
Kotter John P. Kotter; 1995 article, 1996 book Leadership and collective implementation Urgency, coalition, vision, communication, enabling action, wins, further change, cultural anchoring 3 Support for components does not validate the whole sequence (Appelbaum et al., 2012)
ADKAR Jeff Hiatt, Prosci; developed 1996, first published 1999, book 2006 (as reported by Prosci) Individual adoption Awareness, Desire, Knowledge, Ability, Reinforcement 3 The available study predicts readiness from ADKAR factors; it does not test whether following the sequence causes successful change (Zine et al., 2025)
Bridges William Bridges; Transitions (1980), organizational application in Managing Transitions (1991) Psychological adjustment Endings, neutral zone, new beginnings 3 (thin) The one study found for this page is small and uncontrolled, with foster youth, not employees (Nesmith, 2025)
McKinsey 7-S Robert H. Waterman, Thomas J. Peters and Julien R. Phillips; 1980 article Organizational alignment Strategy, structure, systems, shared values, skills, style, staff 3 Categories can overlap, and the method is silent on indicators of effectiveness (McCormack et al., 2022)
Kübler-Ross change curve Stages from Elisabeth Kübler-Ross (1969), adapted for workplaces by later writers Emotional reactions to change Commonly denial, anger, bargaining, depression, acceptance 4 Stage theory is contested in grief research (Stroebe et al., 2017), and the workplace version is a later adaptation (Holdsworth & Bridgman, 2025)
Unfrozen Loop Gabriel Lopez; version 0.2, 2026 The managers in the middle who carry a change A week 0 baseline, five parts on a rhythm, and a culture where it is safe to speak 2 Not yet tested as a whole; grades are provisional and self-assigned

Limitations refer to the sources named in the final column.

Lewin: understand and alter established group practices

The original reference is Lewin's 1947 Human Relations article, Frontiers in Group Dynamics: Concept, Method and Reality in Social Science; Social Equilibria and Social Change. Cummings et al. (2016) report that Lewin wrote of unfreezing, moving and freezing, and that "refreezing" and the later unfreeze, change, refreeze shorthand came from later writers. Lewin's 1947 text was not read for this page.

A practical reading asks what sustains the current behavior, how alternatives can be tried, and how improvements can be supported. Burnes (2004) describes a broader planned approach that includes field theory, group dynamics and action research; Burnes (2020) stresses that the approach was participative and iterative. See Kurt Lewin.

Kotter: organize leadership and implementation

John Kotter introduced the approach in "Leading Change: Why Transformation Efforts Fail" (1995) and expanded it in Leading Change (1996). The eight activities cover urgency, a guiding coalition, vision and strategy, communicating direction, enabling action, short-term wins, further change and cultural anchoring.

Kotter's firm now describes a later evolution into the eight accelerators of his 2014 book Accelerate. This is creator material, not independent validation of either version (Kotter International, n.d.). See Kotter's 8 steps.

ADKAR: investigate individual adoption

Jeff Hiatt developed the model in 1996; Prosci reports that it was first published in a 1999 white paper, and the first ADKAR book, ADKAR: A Model for Change in Business, Government and Our Community, followed in 2006 (Creasey, 2025). That account is creator material.

The five elements are understanding why change matters, wanting to participate, knowing how to act, being able to act, and receiving reinforcement. ADKAR distinguishes learning about a process from performing it successfully. Prosci describes the elements as intentionally sequenced outcomes of individual change (Creasey, 2025). In my reading, ADKAR on its own addresses individual adoption and is not a complete organizational diagnosis. See ADKAR.

Bridges: distinguish an event from a transition

William Bridges developed his account of personal transition in Transitions: Making Sense of Life's Changes (1980), then applied it to organizations in Managing Transitions: Making the Most of Change (1991) (William Bridges Associates, n.d.-b).

Its central distinction is between external change and internal adjustment. The creator describes change as "the external event or situation that takes place" and transition as the inner psychological process people go through as they take it in. The phases are ending what currently is, the neutral zone and the new beginning. This description comes from creator material, not an independent test of the phases (William Bridges Associates, n.d.-a). See the Bridges transition model.

McKinsey 7-S: examine organizational fit

Waterman, Peters and Phillips published "Structure Is Not Organization" in Business Horizons in 1980. McKinsey dates the framework to the late 1970s and describes it as a constellation of interrelated factors with no hierarchy among them (McKinsey & Company, 2008).

Its elements are strategy, structure, systems, shared values, skills, style and staff, with shared values at the center. Strategy, structure and systems are usually called hard elements; the other four, soft. The framework maps interdependencies rather than prescribing a sequence. McKinsey's explanation is creator material. See the McKinsey 7-S framework.

The Kübler-Ross change curve: name the emotional side

Elisabeth Kübler-Ross published On Death and Dying in 1969, about terminally ill patients. Later writers adapted its stages for organizational change in several phases, which Holdsworth and Bridgman (2025) describe as bricolage. The foundation that carries her name says the stages were never meant as a fixed sequence (Elisabeth Kübler-Ross Foundation, n.d.).

The curve's useful prompt is that change has an emotional side. Its risk is treating people as if they will move through set stages in order. See the change curve for the full history and a side-by-side of grief research and workplace evidence.

The Unfrozen Loop: work through the middle

The Unfrozen Loop is the model I built for this site, so it is not an independent framework and should be read with that in mind. Version 0.2 has a week 0 baseline, five parts run on a rhythm, and a culture ring: surface both ways; make sense together, top included; start it close to the work; review on a rhythm, then hold the pace; and the middle's own weather.

Each part lists the strongest evidence found for a related practice, its grade, and what no controlled study has tested yet. For example, Part 4 cites a meta-analysis rated High in which debriefs were linked to about 25% better performance on average than comparison groups (Tannenbaum & Cerasoli, 2013), while its rule of holding off new work while a change settles has no trial and is labeled as judgment. The Loop page says plainly that it is not yet proven as a whole.

What the research says about each

Evidence needs to be separated into three questions: Does a framework offer useful prompts? Has someone applied it in a particular setting? Does following it cause better outcomes than alternatives? Positive answers to the first two do not establish the third.

Only Harrison et al. (2021), McDonnell et al. (2026) and Tannenbaum and Cerasoli (2013) are graded in the evidence library behind the Loop. The other studies below are not graded there, and their descriptions follow what their abstracts or texts state.

How models are used in practice. Harrison and colleagues (2021), a systematic review of 38 health care studies rated Medium in the evidence library behind the Loop, found 12 change management methodologies in use across 10 countries. Kotter's model was the most common (19 studies), then Lewin's (11). The methodologies were often used as guiding principles, and the authors identified a lack of prescriptive application. McDonnell and colleagues (2026), a systematic review of 17 studies of virtual care, also rated Medium, found Kotter's 8-step model the most frequently applied, often combined with other approaches. Common barriers included an overemphasis on technology at the expense of people and processes, linear application of models, and no way to monitor progress. In these health care reviews, then, the models were mostly guides that people adapted, which is a reason to be cautious about any claim that a model works because it was followed step by step.

Lewin: historical criticism and a substantive defense. Independent scholars disagree about attribution and interpretation. Cummings et al. (2016) challenge the textbook model's provenance. Burnes (2020) defends its substantive grounding in field theory and describes Lewin's approach as participative and iterative; Burnes (2004) argues that the main criticisms of Lewin are misplaced and that his planned approach remains relevant. These historical and conceptual papers do not establish comparative effectiveness.

Kotter: useful components, incomplete whole-model validation. Appelbaum et al. (2012) found literature supporting most components but no formal studies covering the complete model. They still recommended it as a planning reference, supplemented for local obstacles. Pollack and Pollack (2015) report an action-research application that required concurrent processes and engagement across levels, one way practice departed from a linear diagram. Kotter's book and his firm's claims remain creator material, distinct from these independent studies.

ADKAR: empirical work exists, but the claim matters. Zine et al. (2025) used ADKAR factors in predictive models of e-learning readiness, drawing on interviews and questionnaires from 530 students and professors in Algerian universities. That offers evidence about prediction in a particular context, not a causal test of moving people through the prescribed sequence. Prosci's practitioner benchmarking links reported change management effectiveness with reported project outcomes. It is vendor research, and the reported association is not an ADKAR-specific experiment (Anderson, 2026).

Bridges: a useful distinction, limited transferable evidence. Nesmith (2025) reports an exploratory application of the Bridges framework with 35 young people leaving foster care, without a control group. It cannot validate workplace effectiveness or show that employees pass through three phases. In one test of a different stage model, Isabella's account of how managers' interpretations of change evolve, managers' retrospective accounts gave some support to discrete stages while real-time accounts did not follow them (Brotheridge, 2005).

McKinsey 7-S: applications and specific limitations. McCormack et al. (2022), independent of McKinsey, adapted 7-S to develop a curriculum framework for health care education. They valued its central shared values and equal, interconnected elements, found considerable overlap between components such as staff and skills, and noted that it is silent on indicators of effectiveness. Chmielewska et al. (2022) used 7-S to organize a survey of 249 physicians in Warsaw public hospitals. Neither tests whether better fit improves performance.

Kübler-Ross change curve: a contested borrowing. Maciejewski et al. (2007) found grief indicators peaking in the order stage theory predicts among bereaved people, while Stroebe et al. (2017) listed the absence of sound empirical evidence among major concerns about the stage approach and argued that it should be discarded. Holdsworth and Bridgman (2025) find the workplace curve relatable but universal and linear in its view of emotions.

The Unfrozen Loop: tested pieces, untested whole. The Loop's parts cite randomized trials, field experiments and a meta-analysis of related practices, graded on a rubric set out on the Atlas page. Those grades are my own and provisional, and no study tests the Loop as a whole.

Across all seven frameworks, research scope and methods differ too much to turn these sources into a defensible league table.

Where the evidence is thin

  1. No head-to-head trials. In the sources reviewed here, none of the seven models has been tested as a whole against an alternative in a controlled study.
  2. Practice reviews are from health care. Among the sources reviewed here, the two reviews of how models are used in practice are both from health care, and both include R. Harrison as an author (Harrison et al., 2021; McDonnell et al., 2026).
  3. Creator material. In the sources reviewed here, the descriptions of Kotter's steps and of ADKAR come from their creators (Kotter International; Prosci), which is not independent evidence.

Other frameworks in this encyclopedia answer neighboring questions: the change management process sets the models' shared steps side by side, the Burke-Litwin model and the competing values framework are tools for diagnosis and culture, and organizational change management covers the discipline as a whole.

Using them together

Practice recommendation, not a proven method. Combine only the questions your situation requires.

A business redesigning its customer service operation could use 7-S to investigate conflicting targets, staffing, systems and skills. Kotter could help coordinate leadership responsibilities. ADKAR could help managers distinguish missing knowledge from insufficient ability to use the revised process. Bridges could guide conversations about lost responsibilities or team identity. Lewin's broader perspective could keep attention on group practices, experimentation and sustaining improvements. The Loop could set the rhythm of reviews the managers run.

This is a proposed division of work, not a validated combined methodology. Avoid assigning employees to stages based on assumptions. Use interviews, observations, operational data and feedback to decide what support or redesign is needed, then check whether the intervention helped.

Which fits your situation?

  • A customer support team completes training but still cannot use its new ticketing system reliably: Start with ADKAR. Check whether the difficulty concerns knowledge, practice, permissions or support. Add 7-S if organizational targets or systems conflict with the required behavior.
  • A company's regional offices interpret a new strategy differently: Start with Kotter. Establish a shared direction, a coalition with relevant influence and coordinated action. Use local feedback to revise the implementation plan.
  • A healthcare organization merges two teams, and staff are uncertain about roles and relationships: Start with Bridges. Ask what is ending, what remains unclear and what a workable new role looks like. Add 7-S to examine staffing and reporting arrangements; do not assume every employee feels the same loss.
  • A nonprofit changes its reporting lines but delays and duplicated work continue: Start with 7-S. Examine systems, skills, leadership behavior, staffing and shared priorities alongside structure. Use Lewin's group questions when testing and embedding a revised working routine.
  • Managers are carrying a change on top of everything else, and bad news is not reaching you: Start with the Unfrozen Loop's first and fifth parts. The free two-minute self-check shows the weakest part, and the free Team Loop Check shows where your managers agree and split.

These are starting recommendations, not predictions that a named model will produce success.

How the models map to the Unfrozen Loop

  1. Week 0
    Before you start

    Several of these models start with diagnosis, such as 7-S, or with preparation, such as Kotter's first steps. The Loop's Week 0 adds a baseline shared back with the people who supplied it.

  2. 1
    Surface both ways

    The 2026 health care review below lists no way to monitor progress among its common barriers. The Loop's first part is about bad news and ideas reaching the people who can act on them.

  3. 2
    Make sense together, top included
  4. 3
    Start it close to the work
  5. 4
    Review on a rhythm, then hold the pace

    The strongest graded evidence on this page, debriefs linked to about 25 percent better performance than comparison conditions, sits under the Loop's fourth part, review on a rhythm.

  6. 5
    The middle’s own weather
  7. Ring
    Safe to speak, and speaking changes something

Highlighted parts are the ones this idea speaks to. The mapping is my reading, not a tested finding. See the whole Loop and the evidence for each part.

The Loop is meant to sit underneath the other models, not replace them. A leader can plan with Kotter, diagnose with 7-S and coach individuals with ADKAR, and still use the Loop's parts to check whether the middle can carry the plan: whether bad news is surfacing, whether managers and the people above have made sense of the change together, whether it is being run close to the work, whether reviews keep running, and whether the managers have room to do it.

Free lesson: Module 0 of Leading Change with Evidence, about 50 minutes.

Common questions

Which change management model is best?

The sources reviewed here do not establish one best model across settings. Match the framework to the question: group practices, leadership coordination, individual adoption, psychological transition, organizational alignment or emotional reactions.

Which change model has the strongest evidence?

None of the seven has been tested as a whole against an alternative in a controlled study, in the sources reviewed here. Kotter's steps have literature support for most components; ADKAR has one predictive study among the sources reviewed; 7-S and Bridges have applications; the change curve borrows stages that are contested in grief research. The Unfrozen Loop is built from trials of related practices, and the Loop itself is untested.

Are all these models step-by-step processes?

No. Kotter describes leadership activities, ADKAR describes individual adoption outcomes, Bridges describes psychological transition, 7-S identifies interdependent organizational elements, and the change curve describes emotional reactions. Lewin's familiar three-step formulation also has a debated history.

Can several models be used together?

Yes, as a practice recommendation, because their purposes differ. A 2026 review of digital change in health care found Kotter often combined with other approaches. The studies discussed here do not validate a combined method or show that adding more frameworks improves results.

Can a small organization use these models?

A small business or nonprofit can use their questions without building a large change program. Start with the immediate problem and add detail only when it helps decisions, responsibilities or evaluation.

Related

Sources

  1. Anderson, S. (2026, August 7). The correlation between change management and project success. Prosci. https://www.prosci.com/blog/the-correlation-between-change-management-and-project-success (vendor material)
  2. Appelbaum, S. H., Habashy, S., Malo, J.-L., & Shafiq, H. (2012). Back to the future: Revisiting Kotter's 1996 change model. Journal of Management Development, 31(8), 764-782. https://doi.org/10.1108/02621711211253231 (abstract read)
  3. Bridges, W. (1980). Transitions: Making sense of life's changes. Addison-Wesley. (catalog record checked)
  4. Bridges, W. (1991). Managing transitions: Making the most of change. Addison-Wesley. (catalog record checked)
  5. Brotheridge, C. M. (2005). A test of the evolution and predictive capacity of managers' interpretations of change. Journal of Change Management, 5(3), 281-294. https://doi.org/10.1080/14697010500216559 (abstract read)
  6. Burnes, B. (2004). Kurt Lewin and the planned approach to change: A re-appraisal. Journal of Management Studies, 41(6), 977-1002. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-6486.2004.00463.x (abstract read)
  7. Burnes, B. (2020). The origins of Lewin's three-step model of change. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 56(1), 32-59. https://doi.org/10.1177/0021886319892685 (accepted version read)
  8. Chmielewska, M., Stokwiszewski, J., Markowska, J., & Hermanowski, T. (2022). Evaluating organizational performance of public hospitals using the McKinsey 7-S framework. BMC Health Services Research, 22(1), Article 7. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-021-07402-3 (full text read)
  9. Creasey, T. (2025, November 20). ADKAR: Core to the people side of change. Prosci. https://www.prosci.com/blog/adkar-core-to-the-people-side-of-change (creator material)
  10. Cummings, S., Bridgman, T., & Brown, K. G. (2016). Unfreezing change as three steps: Rethinking Kurt Lewin's legacy for change management. Human Relations, 69(1), 33-60. https://doi.org/10.1177/0018726715577707 (accepted manuscript read)
  11. Elisabeth Kübler-Ross Foundation. (n.d.). The 5 stages of grief. https://www.ekrfoundation.org/5-stages-of-grief/
  12. Harrison, R., Fischer, S., Walpola, R. L., Chauhan, A., Babalola, T., Mears, S., & Le-Dao, H. (2021). Where do models for change management, improvement and implementation meet? A systematic review of the applications of change management models in healthcare. Journal of Healthcare Leadership, 13, 85-108. https://doi.org/10.2147/JHL.S289176 (abstract read)
  13. Holdsworth, L., & Bridgman, T. (2025). From coping with dying to coping with organizational change: The bricolage of the change curve's evolution. Journal of Organizational Change Management, 38(8), 254-269. https://doi.org/10.1108/jocm-05-2025-0479 (abstract read)
  14. Kotter, J. P. (1995, March-April). Leading change: Why transformation efforts fail. Harvard Business Review. https://hbr.org/1995/03/leading-change-why-transformation-efforts-fail-2
  15. Kotter, J. P. (1996). Leading change. Harvard Business School Press. (summary read)
  16. Kotter International. (n.d.). The 8-step process for leading change. https://www.kotterinc.com/methodology/8-steps/ (creator material)
  17. Kübler-Ross, E. (1969). On death and dying. Macmillan. (catalog record checked)
  18. Lewin, K. (1947). Frontiers in group dynamics: Concept, method and reality in social science; social equilibria and social change. Human Relations, 1(1), 5-41. https://doi.org/10.1177/001872674700100103 (summary read)
  19. Maciejewski, P. K., Zhang, B., Block, S. D., & Prigerson, H. G. (2007). An empirical examination of the stage theory of grief. JAMA, 297(7), 716-723. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.297.7.716 (abstract read)
  20. McCormack, B., Magowan, R., O'Donnell, D., Phelan, A., Štiglic, G., & van Lieshout, F. (2022). Developing a person-centred curriculum framework: A whole-systems methodology. International Practice Development Journal, 12(Suppl), Article 2, 1-11. https://doi.org/10.19043/ipdj.12suppl.002 (full text read)
  21. McDonnell, R., Chauhan, A., Adams, C., Cardenas, A., Moscova, M., Walsan, R., Sina, M., Munro, A., Manias, E., Mitchell, R., Gust, A., Sabesan, S., & Harrison, R. (2026). Applying change models and methods during a period of vast digital transformation: A systematic review of practice in healthcare. The International Journal of Health Planning and Management, 41(5), 1032-1053. https://doi.org/10.1002/hpm.70092 (abstract read)
  22. McKinsey & Company. (2008, March 1). Enduring ideas: The 7-S framework. McKinsey Quarterly. https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/people-and-organization/our-insights/enduring-ideas-the-7-s-framework (creator material; summary read)
  23. Nesmith, A. A. (2025). Managing major life changes: An exploratory study using the Bridges transitions framework to help foster youth prepare for discharge. Children, 12(1), Article 22 (online 2024). https://doi.org/10.3390/children12010022 (abstract read)
  24. Pollack, J., & Pollack, R. (2015). Using Kotter's eight stage process to manage an organisational change program: Presentation and practice. Systemic Practice and Action Research, 28(1), 51-66. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11213-014-9317-0 (preprint read)
  25. Stroebe, M., Schut, H., & Boerner, K. (2017). Cautioning health-care professionals: Bereaved persons are misguided through the stages of grief. OMEGA: Journal of Death and Dying, 74(4), 455-473. https://doi.org/10.1177/0030222817691870 (abstract read)
  26. Tannenbaum, S. I., & Cerasoli, C. P. (2013). Do team and individual debriefs enhance performance? A meta-analysis. Human Factors, 55(1), 231-245. https://doi.org/10.1177/0018720812448394 (as graded for the Unfrozen Loop)
  27. Waterman, R. H., Peters, T. J., & Phillips, J. R. (1980). Structure is not organization. Business Horizons, 23(3), 14-26. https://doi.org/10.1016/0007-6813(80)90027-0 (title and record only)
  28. William Bridges Associates. (n.d.-a). What is transition? https://wmbridges.com/what-is-transition/ (creator material)
  29. William Bridges Associates. (n.d.-b). William Bridges bio. https://wmbridges.com/about/william-bridges-bio (creator material)
  30. Zine, M., Harrou, F., Terbeche, M., & Sun, Y. (2025). Evaluating e-learning readiness using explainable machine learning and key organizational change factors in higher education. Education and Information Technologies, 30(9), 12905-12937. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10639-025-13335-9 (abstract read)