Home / OD Encyclopedia / Kotter vs ADKAR: purpose and evidence
OD Encyclopedia · Comparison
Kotter vs ADKAR: purpose and evidence
Kotter helps leaders organize a change effort; ADKAR helps them examine what individuals need to adopt it. Both offer useful questions, but the studies reviewed here do not test either as a universal recipe.
By Gabriel Lopez · Updated October 26, 2026 · Every source is listed at the end
In brief
Kotter's eight steps focus on mobilizing an organization: establishing direction, building support, removing obstacles, and sustaining change. ADKAR focuses on individual adoption: understanding why change is needed, wanting to participate, knowing how, being able to act, and maintaining the new behavior (Kotter, 1996; Hiatt, 2006). Use Kotter to structure leadership and coordination, and ADKAR to investigate adoption barriers. Combining them is practice, not proven superiority.
Side by side
| Comparison | Kotter's eight steps | ADKAR |
|---|---|---|
| Creator and timing | John P. Kotter; 1995 article, expanded in a 1996 book | Jeff Hiatt, Prosci founder; 2006 book, with earlier development reported by Prosci |
| Main focus | Organization and collective change leadership | Individual adoption within organizational change |
| Steps or elements | Urgency; coalition; vision; communication; enabling action; early wins; continued change; cultural anchoring | Awareness; Desire; Knowledge; Ability; Reinforcement |
| Typical use | Planning a transformation involving multiple teams and leaders | Diagnosing adoption difficulties and planning communication, coaching, training, and support |
| Main criticism or limitation | A centrally led sequence can oversimplify complex, overlapping change | Focuses on individuals, so structural barriers need separate attention; independent tests of the full prescribed sequence are scarce |
ADKAR is part of Prosci's broader methodology, not its entire organizational change process (Prosci, n.d.).
Kotter's 8 steps in brief
John Kotter introduced the framework in the 1995 Harvard Business Review article "Leading Change: Why Transformation Efforts Fail," expanding it in Leading Change (1996). Its foundation was organizational observation, not a controlled comparison of models (Kotter, 1995, 1996).
In plain English, the original eight steps are:
- Establish urgency: Explain why continuing as before is risky or misses an opportunity.
- Build a guiding coalition: Assemble people with enough influence to lead the effort.
- Develop a vision and strategy: Describe the intended future and how to reach it.
- Communicate the vision: Help people understand the direction through words and actions.
- Enable broad action: Remove systems, structures, or other obstacles that block participation.
- Generate short-term wins: Produce visible improvements that demonstrate progress.
- Consolidate gains and continue changing: Use early success to tackle further problems.
- Anchor new approaches in culture: Connect new practices with results and reinforce them through organizational routines.
These paraphrase the original framework. Kotter's firm now describes eight "accelerators"; evidence about the original model should not automatically be transferred to that evolution (Kotter International, n.d.).
ADKAR in brief
Jeff Hiatt, founder of the change management company Prosci, set out ADKAR in the 2006 book ADKAR: A Model for Change in Business, Government and Our Community. Prosci reports that Hiatt developed the model in 1996 and first published it in a 1999 white paper, "The Perfect Change" (Creasey, 2025).
Its five elements describe outcomes for an individual, rather than five project activities:
- Awareness: Understanding why the change is needed.
- Desire: Willingness to participate in and support it.
- Knowledge: Knowing what to do and how to do it.
- Ability: Being able to perform the required behavior in practice.
- Reinforcement: Support that helps the change last.
Knowledge and ability differ: completing training does not establish competent performance. Prosci presents the elements as sequential building blocks for identifying adoption barriers (Hiatt, 2006; Creasey, 2025).
What the research says about each
Only Harrison and colleagues (2021) is graded in the Evidence Library, at Medium from its abstract. The other studies here are not graded and are described from their abstracts.
Kotter has independent scrutiny, but limited validation of the complete model. Appelbaum and colleagues' 2012 literature review found support for most individual steps, but no formal studies covering the model's complete structure. This supports considering its components; it does not demonstrate that eight steps are necessary, sufficient, or optimal in that order.
Pollack and Pollack's (2015) action research found a knowledge management initiative required engagement at multiple levels and concurrent versions of the process. This challenges a simple linear reading, without establishing a universal alternative.
Hughes (2016) questions Leading Change's continuing relevance and limited engagement with published scholarship. His conceptual critique does not experimentally demonstrate worse outcomes.
ADKAR has independent applications and empirical studies, but those test different things. Balluck, Asturi, and Brockman (2020), writing as nurse leaders rather than Prosci researchers, describe using ADKAR alongside another model, CLARC, during a staffing transition. Their implementation account does not isolate ADKAR's contribution.
Zine and colleagues (2025) used interview and questionnaire data from 530 students and professors in Algerian universities to predict e-learning readiness from ADKAR factors using machine learning. This tests prediction in one setting, not whether the prescribed sequence causes better adoption than alternatives.
Harrison and colleagues' (2021) healthcare systematic review included 38 studies: 19 used Kotter and one ADKAR. These counts concern healthcare within the review's scope. Frameworks were often flexible guides; the review establishes no comparative winner.
Creator reports are a separate category of evidence. A Prosci blog post on its benchmarking data reports that practitioners who rated their change management as more effective also more often reported meeting project objectives (Anderson, 2026). This is neither independent nor an ADKAR-specific causal test. Kotter's own observations likewise explain the framework's origins without independently validating its superiority.
Both can organize useful work, but evidence for universal sequences and comparative superiority remains thin. Managers should avoid promising results on a model's name alone.
Where the evidence is thin
- No head-to-head test. None of the sources here compares changes run with Kotter against changes run with ADKAR.
- Whole models. For Kotter, a review found support for most individual steps but no formal study of the whole model (Appelbaum et al., 2012). For ADKAR, the studies here use it as a framework or survey, not as a test of its sequence.
- Creator data. In the sources reviewed here, the support offered for each model as a whole comes largely from its creator's own observations or benchmarking, which is not independent evidence.
How they map to the Unfrozen Loop
- Week 0Before you start
- 1Surface both ways
- 2Make sense together, top included
ADKAR's Awareness and Desire, and Kotter's urgency and vision, are both about people working out why a change matters. The Loop asks for that to happen together, with the people above saying what it costs.
- 3Start it close to the work
ADKAR's Knowledge and Ability are tested close to the work, where a person tries the new way with the time and tools they have. Kotter's step on removing barriers is the organizational side of the same problem.
- 4Review on a rhythm, then hold the pace
Both models end with making the change last, through Reinforcement or by anchoring it in the culture. The Loop's version is a review that keeps running after launch.
- 5The middle’s own weather
- RingSafe to speak, and speaking changes something
Highlighted parts are the ones this idea speaks to. The mapping is my reading, not a tested finding. See the whole Loop and the evidence for each part.
Using them together
Practitioners can use Kotter for collective action and ADKAR for individual needs. This is a practice recommendation, not a proven combined intervention.
For example, a coalition might coordinate a new customer service process while managers use ADKAR questions to distinguish unclear purpose from missing skills or insufficient practice time. Kotter's work on removing obstacles can then address problems uncovered through those conversations.
Avoid mapping eight steps directly onto five outcomes. Teams may need different support simultaneously. Measure actual use, work quality, and feedback; completed activities do not establish adoption.
Which fits your situation?
- Leaders disagree about a major restructuring: Start with Kotter to clarify direction, sponsorship, and coordination. Employee training will not resolve conflicting leadership decisions.
- A team understands a new tool but struggles to use it: Start with ADKAR to distinguish knowledge from ability. Observe the work and check access, practice time, and support.
- An organization is replacing a core operating system: Consider both. Coordinate dependencies and leadership through Kotter, while investigating adoption needs by role through ADKAR.
- Employees reject a process that adds unnecessary work: Investigate and redesign the process first. Either framework can prompt questions, but neither should turn justified criticism into an employee motivation problem.
Free lesson: Module 0 of Leading Change with Evidence, about 50 minutes.
Common questions
Which is better, ADKAR or Kotter?
Neither is established as universally better by the research reviewed here. Choose according to whether your immediate problem concerns organizational coordination, individual adoption, or both.
Is ADKAR a replacement for Kotter?
They address different levels of change, so replacement is not the most useful comparison. ADKAR can help examine adoption within an initiative organized around Kotter's steps.
Are these models scientifically proven?
Independent researchers have studied applications and reviewed evidence, but application is different from causal validation. Neither the studies discussed here nor creator reports establish that following either model guarantees success.
Must the stages happen in order?
Both frameworks describe a progression, and Prosci explicitly presents ADKAR's elements as sequential. However, prescribed order should not be confused with proof that every change follows it; one action-research case using Kotter's model ran several overlapping instances of the process at once (Pollack & Pollack, 2015).
Related
Sources
- Anderson, S. (2026, August 7). The correlation between change management and project success. Prosci. https://www.prosci.com/blog/the-correlation-between-change-management-and-project-success
- Appelbaum, S. H., Habashy, S., Malo, J.-L., & Shafiq, H. (2012). Back to the future: Revisiting Kotter's 1996 change model. Journal of Management Development, 31(8), 764-782. https://doi.org/10.1108/02621711211253231 (abstract read)
- Balluck, J., Asturi, E., & Brockman, V. (2020). Use of the ADKAR and CLARC change models to navigate staffing model changes during the COVID-19 pandemic. Nurse Leader, 18(6), 539-546. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mnl.2020.08.006
- Creasey, T. (2025, November 20). ADKAR: Core to the people side of change. Prosci. https://www.prosci.com/blog/adkar-core-to-the-people-side-of-change
- Harrison, R., Fischer, S., Walpola, R. L., Chauhan, A., Babalola, T., Mears, S., & Le-Dao, H. (2021). Where do models for change management, improvement and implementation meet? A systematic review of the applications of change management models in healthcare. Journal of Healthcare Leadership, 13, 85-108. https://doi.org/10.2147/JHL.S289176
- Hiatt, J. (2006). ADKAR: A model for change in business, government, and our community. Prosci. (summary read)
- Hughes, M. (2016). Leading changes: Why transformation explanations fail. Leadership, 12(4), 449-469. https://doi.org/10.1177/1742715015571393 (abstract read)
- Kotter, J. P. (1995, March-April). Leading change: Why transformation efforts fail. Harvard Business Review, 59-67. https://hbr.org/1995/05/leading-change-why-transformation-efforts-fail-2
- Kotter, J. P. (1996). Leading change. Harvard Business School Press. (summary read)
- Kotter International. (n.d.). The 8-step process for leading change. https://www.kotterinc.com/methodology/8-steps/
- Pollack, J., & Pollack, R. (2015). Using Kotter's eight stage process to manage an organisational change program: Presentation and practice. Systemic Practice and Action Research, 28(1), 51-66. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11213-014-9317-0 (abstract and preprint read)
- Prosci. (n.d.). The Prosci ADKAR model. https://www.prosci.com/methodology/adkar
- Zine, M., Harrou, F., Terbeche, M., & Sun, Y. (2025). Evaluating e-learning readiness using explainable machine learning and key organizational change factors in higher education. Education and Information Technologies, 30(9), 12905-12937. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10639-025-13335-9 (abstract read)