Part 5 of the Unfrozen Loop · candidate

The middle's own weather

Workload, competing initiatives and strain on the managers carrying the change.

Every other part of the Loop runs through people who are already stretched. These studies describe the pressure on middle managers during change: the load, the conflicting demands, the emotional work. A candidate fifth part of the Loop.

42studies inform this part

40 support · 2 mixed · 0 challenge · 0 rated high strength

See the whole Loop, version 0.1: every part with its sign and a first move.

Questions about this part

Supports 40 studies

Li & Makino (2025) · qualitative case · MediumTurning Fear Into a Weapon for Change in Response to Threats: A Partnership ApproachFear pushed middle managers both toward inertia and toward change; treating them as partners, with independence from assessment, in decision making and from structural constraints, reduced rigidity by reshaping those fears.Esper et al. (2025) · mixed · MediumBetween Strategy and Reality: Middle Managers’ Responses to CSR DecouplingMiddle managers judged all kinds of CSR decoupling negatively, were most likely to act when peers caused it, and leaned toward resigning when top managers caused it because of the emotional toll.Wang et al. (2024) · survey · MediumMiddle Managers’ Role Overload, Workplace Anxiety, and Resistance to Change: The Moderating Effect of Emotion Regulation StrategiesMiddle managers who reported more role overload also reported more resistance to change, and workplace anxiety helped explain the link; their emotion regulation strategies changed how strongly overload was tied to anxiety.Koivunen et al. (2024) · qualitative interviews · MediumHow Managers Experience Downsizing: Navigating among Professional, Loyal, Empathic, and Critical PositionsManagers carrying out a downsizing moved between professional, loyal, empathic and critical positions, struggling to meet conflicting expectations from top management and subordinates.Azambuja & Islam (2023) · qualitative case · MediumMiddle‐Managerial Deviance as a Response to Structural Strain: Rescoping, Reconfiguring and Replacing NormsMiddle managers deviated from norms when organizational rules clashed with on-the-ground work; their deviance could adapt or replace norms and fed into new norm formation while expanding their own power.Letierce et al. (2023) · qualitative case · MediumEmpowering middle managers to free their strategic capabilitiesMiddle managers freed from administrative work and backed by structure and top management adapted the prescribed strategy to local conditions and empowered their front-line teams.Hassard & Morris (2021) · other · MediumThe extensification of managerial work in the digital age: Middle managers, spatio-temporal boundaries and controlMiddle managers reported their working time stretching inside the workplace and extending into voluntary work from outside it; the authors link this to lean, agile and reengineering prescriptions and to digital communication tools, and argue that strategic and political choices also shape it.Splitter et al. (2021) · qualitative case · MediumMiddle Managers' Struggle Over Their Subject Position in Open Strategy ProcessesWhen a company opened strategy making to front-line employees, middle managers' traditional role as strategists was undermined, and they took different routes to reclaim it over time.Kim et al. (2021) · survey · MediumWhen CEOs are all about themselves: Perceived CEO narcissism and middle managers’ workplace behaviors amid the COVID-19 pandemic.Middle managers who saw their CEO as narcissistic reported more uncertainty, especially when COVID-19 threatened the firm, and that uncertainty went with more laissez-faire leadership and impression management; an online experiment with working adults supported the model.Larsson & Holmberg (2021) · qualitative interviews · MediumTaming the Survey: Managing the Employee Survey to Create Space for Change Oriented LeadershipMiddle managers reinterpreted, prioritized and embedded a standardized employee survey to create space for local change, and the authors suggest their considerable effort was a critical factor in making the survey useful.Gjerde & Alvesson (2019) · qualitative interviews · MediumSandwiched: Exploring role and identity of middle managers in the genuine middleAcademic middle managers described acting as 'umbrella carriers', shielding their staff from top-management initiatives and information they saw as unnecessary or harmful, a stance tied to identifying more with their profession and staff than with the managerial role.Huy (2011) · qualitative case · MediumHow middle managers' group‐focus emotions and social identities influence strategy implementationIn a three-year case at a large tech firm, executives treating strategy as a purely task-focused job unintentionally stirred middle managers' group identities around tenure and language; the resulting emotions saw managers, even ones executives promoted, back or quietly brush off an initiative.Vuori & Huy (2016) · qualitative case · MediumDistributed Attention and Shared Emotions in the Innovation ProcessAt Nokia, middle managers who feared their superiors and peers shared less bad news upward, while top managers, fearing competitors and shareholders, did not fully reveal how serious the outside threat was; leaders grew overly optimistic and the smartphone effort suffered.Huy et al. (2014) · qualitative case · MediumFrom Support to Mutiny: Shifting Legitimacy Judgments and Emotional Reactions Impacting the Implementation of Radical ChangeOver three years of a radical change, middle managers went from supporting their top leaders to mutiny as they reassessed whether those leaders were legitimate, and their emotional reactions fed rising resistance.Azambuja & Islam (2019) · qualitative case · MediumWorking at the boundaries: Middle managerial work as a source of emancipation and alienationMiddle managers at a Brazilian accounting firm saw themselves as proactive, reflective agents yet also as lacking autonomy and belonging, and routinely shifted between active mediators and mere coordination devices.Chen et al. (2018) · survey · MediumHigh‐commitment work systems and middle managers' innovative behavior in the Chinese context: The moderating role of work‐life conflicts and work climateIn 113 Chinese manufacturing firms, high-commitment HR systems went with more innovative middle managers, but heavy work-family conflict weakened that link, less so where the climate made it easier to share family concerns.Ou et al. (2017) · survey · MediumWhen Can Humble Top Executives Retain Middle Managers? The Moderating Role of Top Management Team FaultlinesAcross 43 top teams, humble executives' link to satisfied middle managers was weaker when the top team was split by faultlines, and those faultlines also blunted how much dissatisfaction pushed managers to quit.Ou et al. (2014) · mixed · MediumHumble Chief Executive Officers’ Connections to Top Management Team Integration and Middle Managers’ ResponsesIn 63 private Chinese firms, humble CEOs were linked to more unified top teams, and middle managers below them saw a more empowering climate and were more engaged, committed and better performing.Hassard et al. (2012) · qualitative interviews · Medium‘My Brilliant Career’? New Organizational Forms and Changing Managerial Careers in Japan, the UK, and USAInterviews with HR managers in large firms in Japan, the UK and the USA found most had downsized and delayered, promotions were scarcer and sideways moves more common, and middle managers were generally resentful.Fu et al. (2010) · mixed · MediumPursuit of Whose Happiness? Executive Leaders' Transformational Behaviors and Personal ValuesIn Chinese firms, middle managers picked up on their CEO's personal values, and a CEO's inspiring behavior went with stronger commitment when the CEO cared about others and weaker commitment when the CEO was self-focused.Gong et al. (2009) · survey · MediumHuman resources management and firm performance: The differential role of managerial affective and continuance commitment.In 463 firms operating in China, HR practices aimed at middle managers' performance went with better firm results, a link running through managers' emotional attachment to the firm; practices aimed at keeping them did not.McCann et al. (2008) · qualitative interviews · MediumNormalized Intensity: The New Labour Process of Middle ManagementIn 64 interviews across five UK organizations going through large-scale restructuring, including delayering and downsizing, middle managers reported more autonomy but longer, more intense hours, closer monitoring and fewer promotion prospects.Zhang et al. (2008) · survey · MediumHow do I trust thee? The employee‐organization relationship, supervisory support, and middle manager trust in the organizationAmong 545 middle managers in China, support from their own boss was more strongly tied to trusting the organization than the employment deal was, strengthening trust's link to investment-style deals and weakening the negative link to purely transactional ones.Van Niekerk & Jansen van Rensburg (2022) · qualitative interviews · LowMiddle Managers’ Strategising Practices to Effect Strategic ChangeProfessional middle managers in a restructuring university used six strategising practices, shaped by cognitive and emotional experience as both implementers and recipients of change.Gibson & Groom (2020) · qualitative case · LowUnderstanding ‘Vulnerability’ and ‘Political Skill’ in Academy Middle Management During Organisational Change in Professional Youth FootballA newly appointed football academy manager handled the ambiguity and job vulnerability of change by managing up, down and across through skilled micro-politics and trust building.Harris & Ogbonna (2019) · other · LowMiddle Managers’ Work in Recession and Austerity: A Longitudinal StudyMiddle managers' early responses to recession and austerity were largely positive but turned to disillusionment and cynicism as they came to believe superiors used austerity as cover for changes that hurt them and their staff.Lüscher & Lewis (2008) · qualitative case · LowOrganizational Change and Managerial Sensemaking: Working Through ParadoxAt Lego, middle managers charged with carrying out a major restructuring struggled for meaning; reflecting jointly with researchers brought their dilemmas into view as paradoxes, and the authors set out a process for working through them.Thakur & Srivastava (2018) · survey · LowFrom resistance to readiness: the role of mediating variablesIn a survey of 276 Indian middle managers, trust, felt organizational support and emotional attachment to the organization helped explain the link between resistance and readiness to change, narrowing the gap between the two.Bardon et al. (2017) · qualitative case · LowIdentity regulation, identity work and phronesisAt Disneyland, middle managers pushed back on a company script that put effectiveness ahead of ethics, recasting themselves as seekers of practical wisdom.Cumberland et al. (2018) · survey · LowAn emergent understanding of influences on managers’ voices in SMEsIn a survey of 202 SME middle managers, bosses' openness to ideas went with higher job satisfaction and engagement, but only engagement was tied to speaking up more.Pors (2016) · qualitative case · Low‘It Sends a Cold Shiver down my Spine’: Ghostly Interruptions to Strategy ImplementationIn conversations at a Danish local government's strategy seminar, middle managers glimpsed darker futures behind the familiar strategy and voiced a sense that something different had to be done, though they could not say what.Harding et al. (2014) · qualitative interviews · LowWho is ‘the middle manager’?Listening to middle managers talk about their work in focus groups, the authors argue they shift between going along with and pushing back on the standard manager role, both controlled and controlling.Smollan (2013) · qualitative interviews · LowTrust in change managers: the role of affectInterviews with 24 people about workplace change found that trust and distrust in supervisors and senior change leaders came loaded with emotion, distrust most intensely, and that perceived fairness built or eroded that trust.Moen & Federici (2012) · experiment · LowThe Effect of External Executive Coaching and Coaching-Based Leadership on Need Satisfaction.Over a year at a Norwegian company the authors describe as a Fortune 500 high-tech firm, executives given outside coaching reported more satisfied needs at work than uncoached executives, and middle managers in a coaching-based leadership program reported more than uncoached managers, by a smaller margin; the study did not test that difference.Berg et al. (2012) · conceptual · LowChanging Leadership and Gender in Public Sector OrganizationsMostly drawing on the literature, plus some findings from Swedish and English higher education and social work, the authors argue new public management goes with masculinist rationality that rewards individual winners and diverts attention from collective gender issues.Bryant & Stensaker (2011) · conceptual · LowThe Competing Roles of Middle Management: Negotiated Order In the Context of ChangeThe authors propose negotiated order as a lens on middle managers juggling competing roles during change, urging study of how they negotiate new ways of working, within themselves, and over how far they can legitimately push.Cross (2010) · qualitative interviews · LowBarriers to the executive suite: evidence from IrelandInterviews with 30 women middle managers in Ireland found many felt pressured to stay put rather than seek promotion as career demands collided with family life, and they saw visibility as key to advancing.Hom et al. (2009) · survey · LowExplaining employment relationships with social exchange and job embeddedness.In two surveys of Chinese managers, including 526 middle managers in 41 firms, generous employer investment in staff was linked to lower quit intentions and more commitment, through a sense of exchange and feeling rooted in the job.Wright (2009) · qualitative interviews · LowInside Out? Organizational Membership, Ambiguity and the Ambivalent Identity of the Internal ConsultantInterviews with HR and organizational development managers working as internal consultants suggest they build an in-between identity, part insider and part outsider, that can be a source of strength as well as strain.Jones et al. (2008) · qualitative interviews · LowEmployee perceptions of organizational change: impact of hierarchical levelIn a hospital facing downsizing and a move, executives talked more about participation and communication, while supervisors and frontline staff talked more about conflict and division.

Mixed 2 studies