Does coaching or leadership development work for middle managers?
The short answer
The evidence is thin: four of the five studies here are rated low strength. In one small year-long study at a Norwegian company the authors describe as a Fortune 500 high-tech firm, executives given outside coaching reported more satisfied needs at work than uncoached executives, and middle managers in a coaching-based leadership program reported more than uncoached managers, by a smaller margin (Moen & Federici, 2012). At Lego, reflecting jointly with researchers brought middle managers' dilemmas into view as paradoxes. Middle managers at one health authority said they needed space for development, partnerships, and mentoring and coaching. A randomized trial, not among middle managers, found training supervisors to support staff's personal lives, together with prompting employees to rethink when and where they work, modestly cut work-family conflict.
Based on 5 studies from the Atlas of the Middle: 0 rated high strength, 1 medium, 4 low. Designs: experiment (2), qualitative case (2), conceptual (1).
Coaching programs
In one small year-long study at a Norwegian company the authors describe as a Fortune 500 high-tech firm, executives given outside coaching reported more satisfied needs at work than uncoached executives, and middle managers in a coaching-based leadership program reported more than uncoached managers, by a smaller margin; the study did not test that difference. One practitioner framework sorts middle managers' work by whom they deal with and whether they are sharing information or shaping views; its authors report it helps their coaching clients, which is their own report rather than a test.
At Lego, middle managers charged with carrying out a major restructuring struggled for meaning; reflecting jointly with researchers brought their dilemmas into view as paradoxes, and the authors set out a process for working through them.
A leadership needs assessment with middle managers at an Atlantic Canada health authority, reaching about half of the program's 150 managers directly, surfaced considerations including making space for development, building partnerships, and mentoring and coaching.
In a randomized trial in a Fortune 500 firm's IT division, training supervisors to support staff's personal lives and prompting employees to rethink when and where they work modestly cut work-family conflict without raising hours. The trial was not among middle managers specifically.
These come from syntheses and trials on organizational change generally, not only middle managers, graded with the same rubric as the Atlas studies.
Haunstrup & Jensen 2024· pre-registered field experiment, 226 managers in 34 Danish job centers · rated High strength
Leadership training plus just-in-time nudges led employees to rate their managers higher on transformational leadership 8 months later (d about 0.35); static and dynamic nudges did not differ. Complete follow-up data came from 1,889 employees, and response fell from 76% to 53%.
It is stronger evidence than anything on the Atlas page that development for managers can shift how staff see them, though it is training with nudges, not coaching.
Hu et al. 2024· systematic review of 13 mostly weaker-design studies in health care, no pooling · rated Medium strength
Coaching, typically aimed at middle managers and lasting about four months, was reported to have a positive impact on leadership development at the manager, organization and staff levels.
It is the Library review closest to the question, and its studies are mostly weaker designs, much like the low-rated Atlas studies.
Collins & Holton 2004· meta-analysis of 83 studies, mixing controlled and single-group pre-post designs · rated Medium strength
Managerial leadership training showed large effects on knowledge, moderate to large effects on expertise and a smaller average effect on organizational outcomes; the largest effects came from single-group pre-post designs without a control group.
It fits the reading on this page that development should be checked against what changes at work: effects were largest on what managers know and smaller on organizational outcomes, and the biggest effects came from single-group pre-post studies.
The Library also holds a companion paper from the same Norwegian sample as the Atlas study (Moen & Federici 2012, Journal of Education and Learning); it is left out here because it is the same sample, not broader evidence.
What I take from it
My read is that the research here is too thin to promise results from coaching middle managers. If I were investing in it, I would tie it to a real change they are carrying and check afterward whether anything changed.
This is my reading, Gabriel Lopez's, not a finding of the studies above.
Common questions
Is executive coaching more effective than coaching for middle managers?
One study cannot settle it. At a Norwegian company the authors describe as a Fortune 500 high-tech firm, the gap in satisfied needs at work between coached and uncoached staff was larger for executives given outside coaching than for middle managers in a coaching-based leadership program, but the two groups also had different coaches and the authors did not test the difference. It is one low-strength study.
What development do middle managers say they need?
A leadership needs assessment with middle managers at an Atlantic Canada health authority, reaching about half of the program's 150 managers directly, surfaced considerations including making space for development, building partnerships, and mentoring and coaching.
Every summary on this page was written by Unfrozen from the study's abstract or full text and checked twice against the source. Loop coding is exploratory and provisional until an independent human coder checks it. Spot an error? Email info@unfreeze.us and it gets fixed.