What leadership style works best for middle managers?
The short answer
Transformational leadership comes out best in the studies we mapped, but every study here is a low- or medium-strength survey showing association. Using 360-degree ratings of 367 managers from 38 UK manufacturers, 215 of them with an agreed hierarchical level, one study found transformational leadership effective at every level, transactional leadership only lower down, and hands-off leadership nowhere (Edwards & Gill, 2012). In two other studies, middle managers' transformational leadership was linked to better frontline performance two levels down, and to supervisors below them feeling more in control and being more creative. In another, developing staff best predicted middle managers' effectiveness. And in one study, peers rated women's leadership less effective in Malaysia than in Australia.
Based on 6 studies from the Atlas of the Middle: 0 rated high strength, 1 medium, 5 low. Designs: survey (6).
It reaches down the line
In three Chinese organizations, middle managers' transformational leadership was linked to better frontline performance two levels down, both directly and by rubbing off on the supervisors in between. At a large joint venture in China, frontline supervisors whose middle managers led in a transformational way felt more in control of their work and were more creative.
Using 360-degree ratings of 367 managers from 38 UK manufacturers, 215 of them with an agreed hierarchical level, one study found transformational leadership effective at every level, transactional leadership only lower down, and hands-off leadership nowhere. In a Swedish multinational, upper managers showed inspiring, role-model leadership more often than middle managers did, and those behaviors were more strongly tied to their subordinates' job satisfaction.
In 360-degree ratings of 49 Chinese middle managers, they focused most on delivering results and monitoring and least on innovating, rated themselves higher than others did, and developing staff best predicted effectiveness.
Surveying 324 middle managers in Malaysia and Australia, the authors found women's leadership was rated less effective by peers in Malaysia than in Australia, which they link to cultural beliefs about women's roles.
These come from syntheses and trials on organizational change generally, not only middle managers, graded with the same rubric as the Atlas studies.
Judge & Piccolo 2004· meta-analysis of 87 sources, including longitudinal and multisource designs · rated Medium strength
Transformational leadership had the highest overall validity (.44), followed by contingent reward (.39), while laissez-faire leadership was negatively related to outcomes (-.37). Contingent reward was more strongly related than transformational leadership to several criteria, and the two correlated .80.
It matches the Atlas pattern (transformational best, hands-off worst) across leaders in general, and adds that rewarding agreed results does nearly as well.
Wang et al. 2011· meta-analysis of 113 studies, pooled correlations · rated Medium strength
Transformational leadership was positively related to individual follower performance, more for contextual than task performance, and to team and organization performance; for individual task performance, contingent reward explained variance beyond transformational leadership.
It supports the Atlas point that leadership style goes with results beyond the immediate team, as association, not cause.
Both are correlational syntheses not specific to middle managers.
What I take from it
My read is that how middle managers lead travels further down than their own team, so I would invest in how they lead, not only in what they are told to deliver. These are associations, so I hold that loosely.
This is my reading, Gabriel Lopez's, not a finding of the studies above.
Common questions
Is transformational leadership effective for middle managers?
In the surveys we mapped, it was associated with better outcomes. In three Chinese organizations, middle managers' transformational leadership was linked to better frontline performance two levels down, and among 38 UK manufacturers it was effective at every level.
Does hands-off leadership work?
Not in one study of 367 managers from 38 UK manufacturers (215 with an agreed hierarchical level), which found transformational leadership effective at every level, transactional leadership only lower down, and hands-off leadership nowhere.
Every summary on this page was written by Unfrozen from the study's abstract or full text and checked twice against the source. Loop coding is exploratory and provisional until an independent human coder checks it. Spot an error? Email info@unfreeze.us and it gets fixed.