What the research says

How can leaders tell a change is stuck before the numbers show it?

The short answer

Look for gaps between what you are told and what the middle sees. In a hospital facing downsizing and a move, executives talked more about participation and communication, while supervisors and frontline staff talked more about conflict and division (Jones et al., 2008). At Nokia, fearful middle managers shared less bad news upward and leaders grew overly optimistic. In one telecom sales unit, reported results were overstated. And in one study, unit managers met years of reforms with cynicism, which the authors read as a way of making sense of contradictions.

Based on 10 studies from the Atlas of the Middle: 0 rated high strength, 7 medium, 3 low. Designs: qualitative case (5), qualitative interviews (2), mixed (2), other (1).

Two stories about the same change

In one hospital, executives and supervisors described the same change in very different terms. In a telecom culture-change workshop, the way senior and middle managers talked to each other shaped what the change came to mean.

Reports that look better than reality

Two cases where what reached the top was rosier than the facts.

Knowledge that stops moving up

Problems and ideas that travel down but not up, or that hierarchy pushes managers to hold back as well as send up.

Cynicism and quiet brush-offs

Signals that show up in how managers talk about, or quietly sidestep, the change. One low-rated study reports that middle managers' largely positive early responses to recession and austerity turned to disillusionment and cynicism. The turn came once they believed superiors used austerity as cover for changes that hurt them and their staff.

When feedback does change practice

One study of when survey feedback led to change.

Broader evidence from the Evidence Library

These come from syntheses and trials on organizational change generally, not only middle managers, graded with the same rubric as the Atlas studies.

  • Molan et al. 2018 · cluster randomized trial, 49 small units of one disability-services nonprofit (N = 430) · rated High strength

    Employees rated their service quality lower than families did, and staff who got their survey results back rated the relational side of their own service higher. Rated from the abstract, so the grade is provisional.

    The Atlas cases show gaps between how different levels see a change; this trial measured a different gap, between staff and the families they serve, and found that feeding survey results back shifted staff perceptions. The outcome is perception, not change progress.

  • An et al. 2022 · randomized field experiment, 672 leaders randomized (504 remained) · rated Medium strength

    Across all leaders, leadership training did not significantly narrow the gap between how leaders and their employees saw the leaders' behavior; the gap narrowed only in public organizations and tended to widen in private ones.

    It supports the Atlas advice to ask how managers and staff describe things, since leaders' own view can stay out of step even after training.

  • Kluger & DeNisi 1996 · meta-analysis of 607 effect sizes (N = 23,663) · rated Medium strength

    Feedback interventions improved performance on average (d = .41), but more than a third of them decreased performance, and feedback was less effective when it drew attention away from the task and toward the self.

    It is about feedback on individual task performance, not about spotting a stuck change; it serves as a caution that returning feedback helps on average but not reliably, which sits alongside the one Atlas study of when survey feedback changed practice.

What I take from it

If I could ask a leader one question, it would be: how would your managers describe this change, and how far is that from how you would? The Team Loop Check is my attempt to measure that gap. It is a conversation starter, not a research instrument.

This is my reading, Gabriel Lopez's, not a finding of the studies above.

Common questions

What are early warning signs that a change is failing?

None of the studies we mapped tests these as early predictors, but they describe: senior leaders and supervisors describing the same change very differently, results that look better than they are, knowledge that moves down more easily than up, and cynicism among the managers carrying it.

Can leaders trust the reports they receive during change?

Not always. At Nokia, fearful middle managers shared less bad news upward. In a telecom desk-sales unit, middle managers coerced their reps into deceiving upper management, so the unit's reported results were overstated.

Every summary on this page was written by Unfrozen from the study's abstract or full text and checked twice against the source. Loop coding is exploratory and provisional until an independent human coder checks it. Spot an error? Email info@unfreeze.us and it gets fixed.

More questions