What the research says

How can middle managers get ideas heard by senior leaders?

The short answer

Frame the idea in senior leaders' terms and time it well: that is where the studies we mapped point, along with the standing of the person pitching it, though much of this comes from cases, theory and practitioner advice. At IBM, after a plasma display bet failed, middle-level champions recast the case for LCDs around business issues rather than technology, and IBM went on to lead LCDs (Eggers, 2016). A theory paper proposes that ideas fitting the firm's current focus are the ones middle managers mostly pass up. In one survey, upward influence was more strongly tied to unit performance for managers with a strong reputation, and practitioner advice drawn from research stresses timing and managing emotions.

Based on 11 studies from the Atlas of the Middle: 0 rated high strength, 8 medium, 3 low. Designs: qualitative case (4), survey (2), experiment (1), conceptual (1), other (1), qualitative interviews (1), mixed (1).

Frame it in their terms

Cases show middle managers shaping how senior leaders, and people at other levels, understand an idea or a change. In an experiment with 180 senior and middle managers, one study reports the two levels chose innovation projects differently, especially radical ones. On radical projects, middle managers weighed internal resources such as social capital and know-how, while senior managers focused on external knowledge.

Fit, timing and reputation

What gets passed up, when, and by whom.

Discontent and secrecy, handled with care

In six manufacturing companies, one study reports that middle managers' discontent could energize upward issue selling, especially when sellers and recipients took each other's perspective. In another, 35 executives recalling their middle-manager years described using secrecy under unfavorable conditions to build support for initiatives. Handled carefully, it increased receptivity; mishandled, it bred resistance and distrust.

What drives them to try

Why middle managers push ideas up, or hold back.

Broader evidence from the Evidence Library

These come from syntheses and trials on organizational change generally, not only middle managers, graded with the same rubric as the Atlas studies.

  • Rigtering et al. 2019 · randomized field experiment, 647 consultants at one firm · rated Medium strength

    Making an idea program opt-out rather than opt-in roughly tripled the number of people who submitted (26 vs 9) without a detectable drop in idea quality. Sending example projects nearly halved submissions and made ideas more useful but less novel. Only 35 people submitted, so the quality comparisons are thin.

    The Atlas studies are about how a middle manager frames an idea for the top; this is about how leaders invite ideas, which supports making it cheaper to bring them.

Only one Library trial bears directly on getting ideas heard.

What I take from it

If you lead from the middle, I would pitch the next idea in the language of the problem your boss is already being judged on. If you lead the middle, I would make it cheaper to bring you ideas that don't fit.

This is my reading, Gabriel Lopez's, not a finding of the studies above.

Common questions

What makes middle managers champion new initiatives?

In a Fortune 500 firm, middle managers' searching for and championing of new strategic initiatives was tied more to how they compared with peers and other units than to how they compared with their own past results.

Does influencing senior leaders always help a middle manager's unit?

Not in a straight line. One survey found middle managers' upward influence related to unit performance along a curve, and the link was stronger for managers with a strong reputation in their networks.

Every summary on this page was written by Unfrozen from the study's abstract or full text and checked twice against the source. Loop coding is exploratory and provisional until an independent human coder checks it. Spot an error? Email info@unfreeze.us and it gets fixed.

More questions