What the research says

How do emotions affect organizational change?

The short answer

In the studies we mapped, they shaped whether managers backed, ignored or resisted a change, and none of the six studies here is rated high strength. In two papers, each based on three years of fieldwork, emotions tied to managers' group identities, and to how they judged their leaders' legitimacy, saw them back an initiative, quietly brush it off, or move toward resistance (Huy, 2011; Huy et al., 2014). At Nokia, fearful middle managers shared less bad news upward and leaders grew overly optimistic. Interviews found trust and distrust in change leaders came loaded with emotion. One paper argues that much apparent shared understanding during a large change was emotional contagion.

Based on 6 studies from the Atlas of the Middle: 0 rated high strength, 3 medium, 3 low. Designs: qualitative case (3), qualitative interviews (1), other (1), survey (1).

Group identities stir emotion

In a three-year case at a large tech firm, executives treating strategy as a purely task-focused job unintentionally stirred middle managers' group identities, and the resulting emotions saw managers back or quietly brush off an initiative. In another paper based on three years of fieldwork during a radical change, middle managers' emotional reactions fed rising resistance as they reassessed whether their leaders were legitimate.

Fear changes what gets said

At Nokia, fearful middle managers shared less bad news upward while top managers did not fully reveal how serious the outside threat was, and leaders grew overly optimistic.

Trust is felt

Interviews with 24 people about workplace change found trust and distrust in supervisors and senior change leaders came loaded with emotion, distrust most intensely, and that perceived fairness built or eroded that trust.

Emotion spreads, and emotional skill goes with readiness

Applying video analysis to middle managers during a large strategic change, one paper argues that much apparent shared understanding was emotional contagion, carried by bodies as well as words. In a survey of 109 middle managers in India's service sector, those scoring higher on emotional intelligence also tended to score higher on readiness for change.

Broader evidence from the Evidence Library

These come from syntheses and trials on organizational change generally, not only middle managers, graded with the same rubric as the Atlas studies.

  • Cherniss et al. 2010 · randomized trial, 162 managers in nine companies · rated High strength

    After two years, managers in the process-designed groups improved more than controls on all multi-rater emotional competence measures. The abstract does not report significance tests, so the grade rests on the design.

    It shows managers' emotional skills can be developed, which the Atlas does not test, but it does not measure any change outcome.

No Library study tests how emotions shape a change. The one item here is about developing managers' emotional skills.

What I take from it

My read is that a change plan that only covers tasks is missing much of what managers react to. Before asking whether people understand a change, I would ask which groups it touches and what people may be afraid to say.

This is my reading, Gabriel Lopez's, not a finding of the studies above.

Common questions

Why do emotions matter in organizational change?

In a three-year case at a large tech firm, executives treating strategy as a purely task-focused job stirred middle managers' group identities, and the resulting emotions saw managers, even ones executives promoted, back or quietly brush off an initiative.

Does fear affect how a change goes?

In the Nokia case, fearful middle managers shared less bad news upward, leaders grew overly optimistic, and the smartphone effort suffered. That is one case, from one company.

Every summary on this page was written by Unfrozen from the study's abstract or full text and checked twice against the source. Loop coding is exploratory and provisional until an independent human coder checks it. Spot an error? Email info@unfreeze.us and it gets fixed.

More questions