Yes, they appear to in the studies we mapped, though most of the evidence is low strength. Among 89 mid-level managers at one U.S. urban hospital, those who spanned boundaries were more strategically active (Pappas & Wooldridge, 2007). Upward influence paid off more for middle managers with a strong reputation in their networks. Clinician-managers balanced proven safety routines with new practice when they had professional legitimacy and strong networks. In two hospitals, change hinged on spaces where reform-minded middle managers and staff could band together. And one conceptual paper argues that bridging gaps between unconnected people is not always the smart move.
Based on 6 studies from the Atlas of the Middle: 0 rated high strength, 2 medium, 4 low. Designs: survey (2), qualitative case (2), qualitative interviews (1), conceptual (1).
Where they sit in the network
Among 89 mid-level managers at a US urban hospital, different kinds of network centrality were tied to different parts of strategic renewal, and managers who spanned boundaries were more strategically active. In another survey, middle managers' influence on those above them related to unit performance along a curve, and paid off more for managers with a strong reputation in their networks.
In UK hospitals, clinician-managers balanced proven safety routines with new practice when they had professional legitimacy, strong networks and a broad view of their professional role.
In two hospitals answering new regulation, change hinged on spaces where reform-minded middle managers and staff could band together. Middle managers from five large French public works firms, meeting as a cross-company study group, made sense of a shared digital design model by translating and reworking ideas together.
One conceptual paper argues middle managers broker between groups in eight different ways, each serving different strategic goals, and that bridging gaps between unconnected people is not always the smart move.
These come from syntheses and trials on organizational change generally, not only middle managers, graded with the same rubric as the Atlas studies.
Balkundi & Harrison 2006· meta-analysis of 37 studies of teams in natural settings · rated Medium strength
Teams with densely connected members performed better and were more committed to staying together, and teams whose leaders were central in networks between groups tended to perform better.
It fits the Atlas finding that boundary-spanning middle managers were more strategically active, at the team level and as association only.
Lam & Schaubroeck 2000· quasi-experiment, 3 matched bank branches · rated Medium strength
Service effectiveness was rated significantly higher in the branch using opinion leaders than in the branch using randomly selected frontline leaders, which in turn beat the branch with none.
It supports giving well-connected people a real role in a change, which the Atlas page suggests; it compares only three branches.
What I take from it
My read is that a middle manager's reach across groups is part of what a change runs on, and an org chart won't show it. Before a change, I would find out who the boundary spanners are and give them a real role in it.
This is my reading, Gabriel Lopez's, not a finding of the studies above.
Common questions
Are boundary-spanning managers more strategic?
In one survey of 89 mid-level managers at a US urban hospital, managers who spanned boundaries were more strategically active, and different kinds of network centrality were tied to different parts of strategic renewal. It is one low-strength survey.
Should middle managers always bridge between groups?
Not according to one conceptual paper, which argues middle managers broker between groups in eight different ways, each serving different strategic goals, and that bridging gaps between unconnected people is not always the smart move.
Every summary on this page was written by Unfrozen from the study's abstract or full text and checked twice against the source. Loop coding is exploratory and provisional until an independent human coder checks it. Spot an error? Email info@unfreeze.us and it gets fixed.