What the research says

What encourages middle managers to take initiative and innovate?

The short answer

The studies we mapped tie it to the setting around middle managers, such as leadership, HR systems and how they compare with peers, though all of them show association, not cause. Across 55 units in 27 firms, units with more transformational leadership showed more corporate entrepreneurship, partly through members' shared belief that they could succeed together, and how strong that indirect link was depended on the firm's empowerment climate (Chang et al., 2017). High-commitment HR systems went with more innovative middle managers, but heavy work-family conflict weakened that link. Middle managers' championing of new initiatives was tied more to how they compared with peers than with their own past results. And more autonomy is not a simple lever: for risk-takers, the link between taking initiative and job performance was weaker, and high autonomy widened that gap.

Based on 5 studies from the Atlas of the Middle: 0 rated high strength, 4 medium, 1 low. Designs: survey (4), mixed (1).

Leadership, climate and support

Across 55 units in 27 firms, units with more transformational leadership showed more corporate entrepreneurship, partly through members' shared belief that they could succeed together. In six Thai manufacturing firms, management support, rewards and worker job discretion were tied to internal and financial improvement, while time for idea generation and cross-boundary communication were not significantly tied to corporate entrepreneurship.

HR systems, and what pulls against them

In 113 Chinese manufacturing firms, high-commitment HR systems went with more innovative middle managers, but heavy work-family conflict weakened that link, less so where the climate made it easier to share family concerns.

Who they compare themselves with

In a Fortune 500 firm, middle managers' searching for and championing of new strategic initiatives was tied more to how they compared with peers and other units than to how they compared with their own past results.

More autonomy is not a simple lever

Among 383 middle managers in a multinational, the tie between a tendency to take initiative and job performance was weaker for risk-takers, a gap that widened with high autonomy and narrowed in units with strong performance management.

Broader evidence from the Evidence Library

These come from syntheses and trials on organizational change generally, not only middle managers, graded with the same rubric as the Atlas studies.

  • Lee et al. 2018 · meta-analysis of 105 studies, pooled correlations · rated Medium strength

    Empowering leadership was associated with higher performance, citizenship behavior and creativity at both individual and team levels, and trust in the leader and psychological empowerment carried those links in a meta-analytic model.

    It fits the Atlas finding that leadership and climate go with initiative, for employees in general; like the Atlas studies, it shows association, not cause.

  • Koh et al. 2019 · meta-analysis of 127 studies with structural modeling, correlational · rated Medium strength

    Transformational leadership had a positive overall association with employee creativity that ran through several mediators, while its direct association turned negative once those mediators were included.

    It echoes Chang et al. (2017) in the Atlas, where the link ran partly through shared beliefs, and warns that the leadership link is indirect.

  • Bos-Nehles et al. 2017 · systematic review of 27 articles, content analysis, no pooling · rated Medium strength

    The authors judged training and development, reward, job security, autonomy, task composition, job demands and feedback to be the HR practices best for innovative work behavior.

    It matches the Atlas link between HR systems and innovative middle managers, but it is about employees generally and rests on the authors' judgment across studies.

All three are correlational syntheses about employees in general.

What I take from it

My read is that if you want middle managers to bring new ideas, the system around them matters as much as their own drive. I would look at how they are led and rewarded, and at who they are being compared with.

This is my reading, Gabriel Lopez's, not a finding of the studies above.

Common questions

Does giving middle managers more autonomy help their initiative pay off?

Not simply. Among 383 middle managers in a multinational, the tie between taking initiative and job performance was weaker for risk-takers, a gap that widened with high autonomy and narrowed in units with strong performance management.

Do HR practices affect middle-manager innovation?

In 113 Chinese manufacturing firms, high-commitment HR systems went with more innovative middle managers, but heavy work-family conflict weakened that link. It is one survey, so it shows association rather than cause.

Every summary on this page was written by Unfrozen from the study's abstract or full text and checked twice against the source. Loop coding is exploratory and provisional until an independent human coder checks it. Spot an error? Email info@unfreeze.us and it gets fixed.

More questions