What the research says

Should you cut layers of middle management?

The short answer

The studies we mapped don't test whether cutting layers pays off, but they show two things worth weighing first. In 64 interviews across five UK organizations going through large-scale restructuring, including delayering and downsizing, the middle managers reported more autonomy but longer, more intense hours, closer monitoring and fewer promotion prospects (McCann et al., 2008). And middle managers do work that is easy to lose: in English hospitals, nurse middle managers passed knowledge down to fellow nurses, though they struggled to pass it up or across to doctors, and in four Chinese state-owned firms, middle managers handled local political actors to hit market goals. A theory paper argues they also link new-technology teams to a firm's existing assets.

Based on 9 studies from the Atlas of the Middle: 0 rated high strength, 7 medium, 2 low. Designs: qualitative interviews (3), qualitative case (2), other (1), conceptual (1), survey (1), archival (1).

What the middle carries

Several studies describe bridging work that sits in the middle. Two are arguments rather than tests, and one says calls to cut middle layers overlook it. In multisource data on 188 intergroup dyads, one study reports that middle managers' boundary spanning could substitute for structural coordination between interdependent teams.

Burgess & Currie (2013) · other · LowThe Knowledge Brokering Role of the Hybrid Middle Level Manager: the Case of HealthcareDrawing on healthcare, the authors argue that hybrid middle managers who straddle clinical and managerial work play a strategic role passing knowledge between the two, something calls to cut middle layers overlook.Currie et al. (2015) · qualitative case · MediumHR Practices and Knowledge Brokering by Hybrid Middle Managers in Hospital Settings: The Influence of Professional HierarchyIn hospital care for older people, nurse middle managers could pass knowledge down to fellow nurses but struggled to pass it up the hierarchy or across to doctors; without HR support, the authors warn, a 'broken' rather than 'broker' chain may result.Taylor & Helfat (2009) · conceptual · LowOrganizational Linkages for Surviving Technological Change: Complementary Assets, Middle Management, and AmbidexterityIBM and NCR are used to argue that firms survive technology shifts when middle managers link new-tech teams to existing assets.Guo et al. (2017) · qualitative case · MediumHow middle managers manage the political environment to achieve market goals: Insights from C hina's state‐owned enterprisesIn four large Chinese state-owned firms, operational middle managers actively dealt with local political actors to hit market goals, and the authors suggest they were better placed for this bridging work than top executives or frontline staff.Porck & van Knippenberg (2022) · survey · MediumAn Integrative Model of the Role of Structural, Behavioural, and Cognitive Coordination in Intergroup Effectiveness: How Middle Managers Play a RoleMiddle managers' boundary spanning and shared understanding of strategy between teams could substitute for structural coordination, and the two strengthened each other's association with how well interdependent teams performed together, in multisource data on 188 intergroup dyads.

Who is in the middle matters

In one industry study, differences among individual middle managers explained far more of the gaps between firms than differences among people in innovative roles.

What delayering and downsizing do to those who stay

Two studies of restructured organizations describe what changed for the managers who remained: heavier, more closely watched work, and fewer promotions. A third, after a downsizing at a Finnish manufacturer, reports that managers who carried out layoffs struggled to meet conflicting expectations from top management and subordinates.

Broader evidence from the Evidence Library

These come from syntheses and trials on organizational change generally, not only middle managers, graded with the same rubric as the Atlas studies.

  • Cummings & Estabrooks 2003 · systematic review of 22 studies with quality assessment, no pooling · rated Medium strength

    Among hospital nurses, restructuring with layoffs was followed by lower job satisfaction, professional efficacy, ability to provide quality care and health, along with higher turnover and disrupted team relationships, especially for less experienced nurses and those hit by repeated restructuring. The studies are observational.

    It concerns frontline nurses rather than managers, but it echoes the Atlas finding that people who stay after cuts carry costs.

  • Charness & Levine 2000 · survey vignette experiments (hypothetical layoffs) · rated Medium strength

    Layoffs due to lower demand were judged fairer than those caused by employee suggestions, and layoffs were seen as fairer when the CEO voluntarily shared the pain.

    The Atlas studies do not look at how cuts are judged; this adds that the reason given and whether the top shares the cost shape how fair they seem, from responses to scenarios rather than real layoffs.

No Library study tests whether removing a management layer pays off.

What I take from it

If I were weighing cuts, I would first list what the middle actually moves between groups, and decide who will move it afterward. None of these studies tells you the right number of layers.

This is my reading, Gabriel Lopez's, not a finding of the studies above.

Common questions

Does removing middle managers improve performance?

The studies we mapped do not test that directly. They describe what middle managers do and what delayering did to the managers who remained, not whether the cuts paid off.

What happens to middle managers after delayering?

In 64 interviews across five UK organizations going through large-scale restructuring, including delayering and downsizing, middle managers reported more autonomy but longer, more intense hours, closer monitoring and fewer promotion prospects.

Every summary on this page was written by Unfrozen from the study's abstract or full text and checked twice against the source. Loop coding is exploratory and provisional until an independent human coder checks it. Spot an error? Email info@unfreeze.us and it gets fixed.

More questions