What the research says

What role do middle managers play in strategy?

The short answer

A real one: middle managers help shape strategy, though the research describes their role more than it measures it. Drawing on 262 interviews, one study argues the same role expectations can both free and limit middle managers' strategic action (Mantere, 2008). A review of 25 years of strategy research organized a scattered literature on middle managers. In the cases we mapped, middle and senior managers built shared understanding in informal conversations around formal meetings, a purchasing department wrote its own strategy by telling stories about work, and middle managers shaped their own strategic role during a top-driven renewal. Six of the nine studies here are rated low strength, and none tests whether involving middle managers improves strategy.

Based on 9 studies from the Atlas of the Middle: 0 rated high strength, 3 medium, 6 low. Designs: qualitative case (4), conceptual (2), review/meta-analysis (1), qualitative interviews (1), archival (1).

A large and scattered literature

One review of 25 years of strategy research on middle managers organized a scattered literature into key constructs, relationships and contributions.

The role can free them or limit them

Drawing on 262 interviews, one study argues the same role expectations can both free and limit middle managers' strategic action, depending on enabling conditions. In a top-driven renewal, middle managers built reputation through operational efficiency, then shaped their own strategic role, until top and middle were reinforcing each other's efforts.

Strategy gets made in conversation

In a public administration, middle and senior managers shaped strategy in informal conversations around formal committee meetings. A new purchasing department's manager and employees co-created its strategy in a storytelling workshop, with stories about the past shaping the mission and stories about the future the vision and action plan; the business area director then authorized it. At a local government strategy seminar, middle managers voiced a sense that something different had to be done, though they could not say what.

How top and middle work together

Two conceptual papers propose that how top teams and middle managers interact, including mutual trust, shapes the quality of strategic decisions and how well they are carried out, and that different kinds of renewal give top, middle and front-line managers different roles. In one archival study of 33 organizations, the tie between an operations-oriented top team and management innovation was stronger when top and middle managers had similar professional backgrounds.

Broader evidence from the Evidence Library

These come from syntheses and trials on organizational change generally, not only middle managers, graded with the same rubric as the Atlas studies.

  • León & Arellano 2010 · controlled field comparison of two groups of middle managers in one savings bank · rated Medium strength

    Middle managers using a Balanced Scorecard linked to strategy showed significantly greater consensus with top management, and some managers using the unlinked system lost consensus. The abstract gives no sample size.

    The Atlas studies describe middle managers' part in strategy without testing interventions; this is a controlled comparison of one tool for aligning middle and top, in one bank and with no sample size reported.

Only one Library study bears directly on this question.

What I take from it

My read is that middle managers already take part in strategy through the conversations and stories that decide what a strategy means in practice. I would rather bring that into the open, and invite it, than treat strategy as finished once it leaves the top.

This is my reading, Gabriel Lopez's, not a finding of the studies above.

Common questions

Should middle managers be involved in strategy?

The studies we mapped describe middle managers shaping strategy more than they test whether involving them pays off. In one case, a new purchasing department's manager and employees co-created its strategy in a storytelling workshop, and the business area director then authorized it.

What limits middle managers' role in strategy?

One study drawing on 262 interviews argues that the same role expectations can both free and limit middle managers' strategic action, depending on enabling conditions it identifies for each of four strategic roles.

Every summary on this page was written by Unfrozen from the study's abstract or full text and checked twice against the source. Loop coding is exploratory and provisional until an independent human coder checks it. Spot an error? Email info@unfreeze.us and it gets fixed.

More questions