What the research says

What do middle managers need from senior leaders during change?

The short answer

Two things come up in the studies we mapped: backing from their own bosses, and leaders who attend to relationships as well as tasks. At a large trucking company, a randomized empowerment program (38 treated and 30 control managers) raised unit managers' sense of control only where they felt their own bosses backed them (Logan & Ganster, 2007). In Chinese private firms, humble CEOs were linked to more unified top teams and to more engaged, committed middle managers, and another study found humble executives' link to satisfied middle managers was weaker when the top team was split by faultlines. CEOs' relationship-focused behaviors were tied to middle managers' attitudes. Apart from the randomized program and one conceptual paper, these studies show association.

Based on 6 studies from the Atlas of the Middle: 0 rated high strength, 4 medium, 2 low. Designs: mixed (2), survey (2), experiment (1), conceptual (1).

Backing from above

The only randomized trial here is an empowerment program at a large trucking company, where unit managers' sense of control rose only where they felt their own bosses backed them. A conceptual model of line managers in public services taking on HR duties concludes they need adequate support to do it well.

Humble and unified top teams

In 63 private Chinese firms, humble CEOs were linked to more unified top teams, and middle managers below them saw a more empowering climate and were more engaged, committed and better performing. Across 43 top teams, humble executives' link to satisfied middle managers was weaker when the top team was split by faultlines.

Relationships as well as tasks

In 125 Chinese firms, CEOs' task-focused behaviors were linked directly to firm performance, while their relationship-focused behaviors were linked to middle managers' attitudes, which in turn tied to performance. In other Chinese firms, middle managers picked up on their CEO's personal values, and a CEO's inspiring behavior went with stronger commitment when the CEO cared about others.

Broader evidence from the Evidence Library

These come from syntheses and trials on organizational change generally, not only middle managers, graded with the same rubric as the Atlas studies.

  • Hartviksen et al. 2019 · systematic review and qualitative meta-synthesis of 23 studies, 482 healthcare middle managers · rated Medium strength

    Healthcare middle managers described building leadership capacity through personal development that depended on support from upper management and their context, which contrasted with their usual overloaded work situation; no included study showed effects on care quality.

    It agrees with the Atlas finding that backing from above matters to the middle, from managers' own accounts in health care.

  • Ng & Sorensen 2008 · meta-analysis of pooled correlations · rated Medium strength

    Perceived supervisor support was more strongly related than coworker support to job satisfaction (.52 vs .37), affective commitment (.48 vs .28) and turnover intention (-.36 vs -.19).

    For employees in general, support from one's own boss goes with better attitudes than support from peers, consistent with Logan & Ganster (2007); it is correlational.

What I take from it

My read is that the most useful thing a senior leader can give a middle manager during change is visible backing, and a top team that is not pulling in different directions. I would check both before asking the middle for more.

This is my reading, Gabriel Lopez's, not a finding of the studies above.

Common questions

Does empowering middle managers work without senior support?

In a randomized empowerment program at a large trucking company, unit managers' sense of control rose only where they felt their own bosses backed them.

Does the CEO's style reach middle managers?

In two studies of Chinese firms, it appears to. Humble CEOs were linked to more unified top teams and more engaged, committed middle managers, and middle managers picked up on their CEO's personal values.

Every summary on this page was written by Unfrozen from the study's abstract or full text and checked twice against the source. Loop coding is exploratory and provisional until an independent human coder checks it. Spot an error? Email info@unfreeze.us and it gets fixed.

More questions