How should leaders communicate a change to managers and employees?
The short answer
No study we mapped compares ways of communicating a change head to head, but in one, interviewed employees preferred their supervisors for practical information about a change and saw senior leaders as the source of strategy (Allen et al., 2007). In a government department facing restructure, a follow-up field study in the same paper found that those who rated change communication highly were more open to change, partly through feeling less uncertain. None of the six studies here is rated high strength. In one bank, strategy messages from top and middle managers were tied to frontline awareness in different ways. And in a hospital facing downsizing and a move, executives talked more about participation and communication, while supervisors and frontline staff talked more about conflict and division.
Based on 6 studies from the Atlas of the Middle: 0 rated high strength, 2 medium, 4 low. Designs: qualitative case (2), mixed (1), survey (1), other (1), qualitative interviews (1).
Different messengers for different messages
In one study, interviewed employees looked to supervisors for practical change information and to senior leaders for strategy, and in a government department facing restructure, those who rated change communication highly were more open to change. In a survey at one regional bank, strategy messages from top and middle managers were tied to frontline strategic awareness in different ways, and the two sources interacted.
One practitioner article argues that many managers, even top leaders, do not understand their company's strategy, and suggests how executives and middle managers can fix it.
In one bank branch, a middle manager turned head-office strategy into everyday text-based tools that engaged frontline staff and produced the figures and indicators senior management's change objectives called for.
In a telecom culture-change workshop, senior and middle managers negotiated meaning in two very different patterns, set by how they talked to each other. In one hospital, executives and supervisors described the same change in very different terms.
These come from syntheses and trials on organizational change generally, not only middle managers, graded with the same rubric as the Atlas studies.
Schweiger & DeNisi 1991· quasi-experiment, 2 plants of one organization after a merger announcement · rated Medium strength
The plant that received a realistic merger preview showed fewer dysfunctional outcomes, and the effects lasted through the study.
The Atlas has no study comparing ways of communicating; this compares communicating realistically with not doing so, in only two plants.
Schaubroeck et al. 1994· field experiment in one plant, 173 salaried staff in 12 workshops, with condition set by workshop order rather than at random · rated Medium strength
Explaining why a pay freeze was fair did not lift attitudes overall, but it took the edge off for the people the freeze hurt most, at least right after the session.
It suggests an explanation matters most to the people a change hurts; it does not compare messengers, which is where the Atlas study points.
Parra et al. 2019· randomized experiment, 174 employees responding to a hypothetical change message · rated Medium strength
Employees shown change communication with high-quality arguments reported less resistance to the change than those shown weak arguments.
It fits the Atlas finding that people who rated change communication highly were more open to change, from an imagined message rather than a real one.
No Library study compares senior leaders with direct supervisors as messengers.
What I take from it
My read is that a change needs two messages: the why from senior leaders, and what it means for daily work from the manager people report to. I would brief middle managers early enough to do the second part well, and then ask them how their teams are describing the change.
This is my reading, Gabriel Lopez's, not a finding of the studies above.
Common questions
Who do employees want to hear about a change from?
In one study, interviewed employees preferred their supervisors for practical information about a change and saw senior leaders as the source of strategy.
Does good change communication make people more open to change?
In one government department facing restructure, employees who rated change communication highly were more open to change, partly through feeling less uncertain. That is an association from one setting, not a test of a communication approach.
Every summary on this page was written by Unfrozen from the study's abstract or full text and checked twice against the source. Loop coding is exploratory and provisional until an independent human coder checks it. Spot an error? Email info@unfreeze.us and it gets fixed.