How do you keep middle managers committed and stop them leaving?
The short answer
Invest in middle managers more than in trying to keep them: that is where the studies we mapped point, though none tests cause. In 463 firms operating in China, HR practices aimed at middle managers' performance went with better firm results through managers' emotional attachment to the firm, while practices aimed at keeping them did not (Gong et al., 2009). Generous employer investment in staff was linked to lower quit intentions and more commitment. One theory paper argues the HR systems that work best differ for middle managers. On careers, many women middle managers interviewed in Ireland felt pressured to stay put rather than seek promotion. The strongest study here is rated medium.
Based on 5 studies from the Atlas of the Middle: 0 rated high strength, 1 medium, 4 low. Designs: survey (2), conceptual (1), qualitative interviews (1), qualitative case (1).
Aim at performance, not only retention
In 463 firms operating in China, HR practices aimed at middle managers' performance went with better firm results, a link running through managers' emotional attachment to the firm; practices aimed at keeping them did not.
In two surveys of Chinese managers, including 526 middle managers in 41 firms, generous employer investment in staff was linked to lower quit intentions and more commitment, through a sense of exchange and feeling rooted in the job.
One theory paper argues that the HR systems that work best differ for top teams, middle managers and professionals, and that short-term pressure and favoritism in staffing can keep firms from adopting the effective ones.
Interviews with 30 women middle managers in Ireland found many felt pressured to stay put rather than seek promotion as career demands collided with family life. McDonald's USA top leadership initiated and sponsored a redesign of middle managers' career paths, with a representative group of those managers developing the changes; the authors report over 100 field officers and 3,000 middle managers embraced it.
These come from syntheses and trials on organizational change generally, not only middle managers, graded with the same rubric as the Atlas studies.
Rhoades & Eisenberger 2002· meta-analysis of more than 70 studies, pooled correlations · rated Medium strength
Fairness, supervisor support, and organizational rewards and good job conditions were associated with perceived organizational support, which in turn related to job satisfaction, affective commitment, performance and less withdrawal.
It matches the Atlas finding that investment goes with attachment, for employees in general; it is correlational.
Portocarrero & Burbano 2023· randomized field experiment, 221 new hires at a Latin American bank · rated High strength
New hires assigned to a one-day social impact activity during onboarding left the bank less often over about 10 months (20.9% vs 34.9%), partly through higher perceived organizational justice; effects were larger for men. The control group was small, so the size of the effect is imprecise.
It shows retention moving in a controlled trial, which none of the Atlas studies tests, but for new hires rather than middle managers.
Linos et al. 2022· randomized field experiment, 536 emergency (911) dispatchers in nine U.S. cities · rated Medium strength
911 dispatchers prompted each week to swap advice with peers in other cities reported less burnout four months later, and among those who stayed through the six weeks, resignations fell by more than half. The burnout result comes from the 152 of 536 who answered the survey, and counting everyone randomized, the drop in resignations was not significant.
It concerns frontline staff, not managers, and the retention result is mixed.
No Library trial tests retention of middle managers themselves.
What I take from it
My read is that middle managers stay committed when they can see the organization investing in them, not just trying to hold on to them. During a change, I would be explicit about what it means for their careers.
This is my reading, Gabriel Lopez's, not a finding of the studies above.
Common questions
Do retention-focused HR practices work for middle managers?
In one survey of 463 firms operating in China, HR practices aimed at keeping middle managers were not linked to better firm results, while practices aimed at their performance were, through managers' emotional attachment to the firm.
What reduces middle managers' intention to quit?
In two surveys of Chinese managers, including 526 middle managers in 41 firms, generous employer investment in staff was linked to lower quit intentions and more commitment, through a sense of exchange and feeling rooted in the job.
Every summary on this page was written by Unfrozen from the study's abstract or full text and checked twice against the source. Loop coding is exploratory and provisional until an independent human coder checks it. Spot an error? Email info@unfreeze.us and it gets fixed.