What the research says

How does change affect middle managers themselves?

The short answer

It loads them up: more work, closer monitoring and fewer chances of promotion. In 64 interviews across five UK organizations going through large-scale restructuring, including delayering and downsizing, middle managers reported longer and more intense hours, closer monitoring and fewer promotion prospects, even with more autonomy (McCann et al., 2008). Where large firms downsized and delayered, HR managers described middle managers as generally resentful. They also carry contradictions between roles, and heavy work-family conflict can weaken the link between good HR systems and middle managers' innovation.

Based on 12 studies from the Atlas of the Middle: 0 rated high strength, 9 medium, 3 low. Designs: qualitative interviews (5), qualitative case (2), survey (2), other (1), experiment (1), mixed (1).

More work, fewer prospects

Studies of delayering and downsizing describe what restructuring does to the middle. A later study, in two phases, 2002-2006 and 2015-2019, reports middle managers' working time stretching inside the workplace and into voluntary work outside it. The authors trace it partly to lean, agile and reengineering prescriptions and to digital tools, and argue that strategic and political choices also shape it.

McCann et al. (2008) · qualitative interviews · MediumNormalized Intensity: The New Labour Process of Middle ManagementIn 64 interviews across five UK organizations going through large-scale restructuring, including delayering and downsizing, middle managers reported more autonomy but longer, more intense hours, closer monitoring and fewer promotion prospects.Hassard et al. (2012) · qualitative interviews · Medium‘My Brilliant Career’? New Organizational Forms and Changing Managerial Careers in Japan, the UK, and USAInterviews with HR managers in large firms in Japan, the UK and the USA found most had downsized and delayered, promotions were scarcer and sideways moves more common, and middle managers were generally resentful.Jones et al. (2008) · qualitative interviews · LowEmployee perceptions of organizational change: impact of hierarchical levelIn a hospital facing downsizing and a move, executives talked more about participation and communication, while supervisors and frontline staff talked more about conflict and division.Hassard & Morris (2021) · other · MediumThe extensification of managerial work in the digital age: Middle managers, spatio-temporal boundaries and controlMiddle managers reported their working time stretching inside the workplace and extending into voluntary work from outside it; the authors link this to lean, agile and reengineering prescriptions and to digital communication tools, and argue that strategic and political choices also shape it.

Caught between roles

Middle managers shift between acting and being acted on, and struggle for meaning when they carry out changes others designed. In one study, managers carrying out layoffs at a Finnish manufacturer moved between professional, loyal, empathic and critical positions, struggling to meet conflicting expectations from top management and subordinates. In a low-rated study of a restructuring South African university, professional middle managers used six strategising practices, shaped by cognitive and emotional experience, as managers who both carry out and receive change.

Home and work collide

Work-family conflict shows up in one middle-manager survey, and a randomized trial among IT employees, not middle managers specifically, found it can be reduced.

What the top does matters

The behavior of senior leaders is tied to how engaged, committed and well-performing the middle is. One survey of 200 middle managers reports that those who saw their CEO as narcissistic reported more uncertainty, especially when COVID-19 threatened the firm.

Broader evidence from the Evidence Library

These come from syntheses and trials on organizational change generally, not only middle managers, graded with the same rubric as the Atlas studies.

  • de Jong et al. 2016 · systematic review of 39 longitudinal studies, no pooling · rated Medium strength

    Employee well-being mostly declined after restructuring, with and without staff reductions, in both the short and long term. Communication, information, training, procedural justice, job control, job insecurity and acceptance of the change were the factors that sat between restructuring and well-being.

    It covers employees at every level, and it agrees with the Atlas interview studies that restructuring tends to go with worse experience for those who stay.

  • Solinger et al. 2021 · meta-analysis of 137 longitudinal studies · rated Medium strength

    Unit-level job attitudes were lower during cost-oriented changes such as restructuring and stayed lower afterward, while they rose during people-oriented changes such as HR investments and stayed higher.

    It adds that the kind of change matters, which the Atlas studies of delayering and downsizing do not test; it is observational.

Still untested in the Evidence Library (Loop Part 5): nearly all tested interventions target individuals; no trial tests organizational changes to a middle manager's load.

What I take from it

Before adding a change, I would ask what the managers carrying it will stop doing. In the studies I read, the load landed on them; none tested whether planning for it helps.

This is my reading, Gabriel Lopez's, not a finding of the studies above.

Common questions

Do middle managers get more autonomy after restructuring?

In one study of five UK organizations going through large-scale restructuring, including delayering and downsizing, middle managers reported more autonomy but also longer, more intense hours, closer monitoring and fewer promotion prospects.

Can organizations reduce the strain?

One randomized trial suggests so, though not among middle managers specifically. In a Fortune 500 firm's IT division, training supervisors to support staff's personal lives and prompting employees to rethink when and where they work modestly cut employees' work-family conflict without raising hours.

Every summary on this page was written by Unfrozen from the study's abstract or full text and checked twice against the source. Loop coding is exploratory and provisional until an independent human coder checks it. Spot an error? Email info@unfreeze.us and it gets fixed.

More questions