What the research says

Do middle managers affect performance?

The short answer

Yes, in several kinds of studies, though most show association rather than cause. At a large trucking company, a randomized empowerment program for unit managers (38 treated and 30 control managers) lifted their units' measured performance (Logan & Ganster, 2007). In one industry, differences among middle managers explained far more of the gaps between firms than differences among people in innovative roles. Surveys tie middle managers' leadership, autonomy and treatment to unit, frontline and firm results. In one study of about 500,000 worker survey responses, the link between purpose, clear direction and later firm performance was driven by middle managers' and professional staff's views, not senior executives'.

Based on 11 studies from the Atlas of the Middle: 0 rated high strength, 11 medium, 0 low. Designs: survey (8), archival (2), experiment (1).

The strongest designs

One randomized program and one study comparing individuals' contributions across firms.

Whose views predict results

In about 500,000 worker survey responses from U.S. companies, one study reports that firms whose employees reported both strong purpose and clear direction from management showed higher later performance. The link was driven by the views of middle managers and professional staff, not senior executives or hourly workers.

Leadership, latitude and influence

Surveys link how middle managers lead, how much freedom they have to manage, and how they influence those above them, to results. Others tie middle managers' engaging leadership to employee performance, and their boundary spanning to how well interdependent teams performed together.

Yang et al. (2010) · survey · MediumMiddle Manager Leadership and Frontline Employee Performance: Bypass, Cascading, and Moderating EffectsIn three Chinese organizations, middle managers' transformational leadership was linked to better frontline performance two levels down, both directly and by rubbing off on the supervisors in between.Ahearne et al. (2014) · survey · MediumPerformance impact of middle managers' adaptive strategy implementation: The role of social capitalMiddle managers' influence on those above them related to unit performance along a curve rather than a straight line, and it paid off more for managers with a strong reputation in their networks.Caza (2011) · survey · MediumTesting alternate predictions for the performance consequences of middle managers' discretionAcross European R&D units, middle managers who felt freer to manage their own people tended to run better-performing units, though the link depended on the managers' experience and was limited by unit size.Salas‐Vallina et al. (2020) · survey · MediumThe challenge of increasing employees' well‐being and performance: How human resource management practices and engaging leadership work together toward reaching this goalMiddle managers' engaging leadership went with more genuine implementation of well-being-oriented HRM and was directly linked to employee performance.Porck & van Knippenberg (2022) · survey · MediumAn Integrative Model of the Role of Structural, Behavioural, and Cognitive Coordination in Intergroup Effectiveness: How Middle Managers Play a RoleMiddle managers' boundary spanning and shared understanding of strategy between teams could substitute for structural coordination, and the two strengthened each other's association with how well interdependent teams performed together, in multisource data on 188 intergroup dyads.

How the organization treats them

How firms manage and control their middle managers is tied to firm and implementation results.

Who is in the middle

In 1,101 South Korean organizations, one study links greater gender diversity among middle managers to better HPWS improvement and profitability, but only where subordinates were also gender diverse.

Broader evidence from the Evidence Library

These come from syntheses and trials on organizational change generally, not only middle managers, graded with the same rubric as the Atlas studies.

  • Manthei & Sliwka 2019 · field experiment in one bank (journal version read from its abstract; a 2018 working paper reports 23 randomly drawn treated branches against more than 250 controls) · rated Medium strength

    Branches whose managers got objective performance data earned higher profits, according to the journal abstract. The figure of about 2%, driven by non-core products and larger branches with no change in loan profits, comes from a 2018 working-paper version that is not peer reviewed.

    Like the Atlas randomized program (Logan & Ganster, 2007), this is a controlled test in one firm, and it adds that what managers can see about performance is tied to unit results.

  • Friebel et al. 2022 · long-term field experiment in stores of a large retail chain · rated Medium strength

    Staff turnover fell by a quarter for nine months in treated stores, and managers shifted time toward HR, but store sales were unaffected, as gains from more HR time were offset by less time on customers and goods.

    It shows a manager-level change moving one outcome and not another, a trade-off the mostly survey-based Atlas studies cannot show.

Both are single-firm field experiments.

What I take from it

I read this as a reason to treat middle managers as the place where a change gets carried, not as a cost line. The evidence is stronger on whether they matter than on exactly how.

This is my reading, Gabriel Lopez's, not a finding of the studies above.

Common questions

Is there causal evidence that middle managers matter?

Some. In a randomized empowerment program at a large trucking company, unit managers' sense of control rose only where they felt their own bosses backed them, and their units' measured performance also improved. Most other studies we mapped are surveys that show association.

Do middle managers affect frontline performance?

In three Chinese organizations, middle managers' transformational leadership was linked to better frontline performance two levels down, both directly and through the supervisors in between.

Every summary on this page was written by Unfrozen from the study's abstract or full text and checked twice against the source. Loop coding is exploratory and provisional until an independent human coder checks it. Spot an error? Email info@unfreeze.us and it gets fixed.

More questions