What the research says

Why do middle managers resist change?

The short answer

In the studies we mapped, what gets called resistance usually has a reason behind it. Over three years of a radical change, middle managers went from supporting their top leaders to mutiny as they reassessed whether those leaders were legitimate (Huy et al., 2014). A change that stirs up group identities and emotions can also turn them for or against it. In one telecom takeover, leaders who left them out ran into trouble, and the authors argue that resistance can be a check on over-optimistic plans. One study reads cynicism as a way of making sense of contradictions, and others see pushback as managers keeping room to act or defending their sense of themselves. One survey links role overload to more resistance, with workplace anxiety helping to explain the link.

Based on 12 studies from the Atlas of the Middle: 0 rated high strength, 6 medium, 6 low. Designs: qualitative case (7), survey (2), other (1), qualitative interviews (1), mixed (1).

It follows how leaders treat the middle

Two of the medium-rated studies on this question, the highest grade here, are long case studies by Quy Huy and colleagues. In one, managers moved toward resistance as they reassessed whether their leaders were legitimate. In the other, emotions tied to their own groups led managers to back or quietly brush off an initiative. In a low-rated study, managers' largely positive early responses to austerity turned to cynicism once they believed superiors used it as cover for changes that hurt them and their staff.

Pushback can be a way of making sense

Some researchers argue that what looks like resistance is managers working through contradictions, or keeping room to act. In one study of compensation-system problems, how much managers identified with the system and felt agency explained whether they championed, complied, adapted or resigned.

Overload and fear play a part

One time-lagged survey of 242 middle managers in China tied more role overload to more resistance to change, and workplace anxiety helped explain the link. Another study, of nine firms in China facing threats, reports that fear pushed middle managers toward both inertia and change.

Leaving the middle out can backfire

In one telecom takeover, senior leaders who left out middle managers' voices ran into trouble implementing change, and the authors argue resistance can be a check on over-optimistic plans. Another study shows middle managers building resistance to management decisions in places they made their own.

Trust and support narrow the gap

One survey looked at what sits between resistance and readiness for change.

Broader evidence from the Evidence Library

These come from syntheses and trials on organizational change generally, not only middle managers, graded with the same rubric as the Atlas studies.

  • Deng et al. 2023 · systematic review of 20 quantitative studies, mostly cross-sectional, no pooling · rated Medium strength

    Across 20 mostly cross-sectional studies, trust in management and cognitive flexibility were the only factors linked to all three dimensions of resistance to change (behavioural, cognitive and affective). Leadership, leader-member relationships, participation, communication and justice were linked with some of them. These are correlations, not causes.

    The middle-manager cases here trace pushback to how managers judged their leaders; this review of employees in general points the same way, with trust in management one of only two factors linked to every dimension of resistance.

  • Peng et al. 2021 · meta-analysis of 30 studies (N = 12,240) · rated Medium strength

    Transformational leadership was associated with more commitment, openness and readiness for change and with less resistance and cynicism about change, but not with support for change. The links with openness and cynicism were stronger in cross-sectional than in longitudinal studies.

    It measures how employees in general react to their leaders, not middle managers reacting to the top, and the weaker longitudinal links are a reason to hold it loosely.

Broader evidence covers employees in general, not middle managers. Both items are correlational.

What I take from it

If middle managers are pushing back, I would ask what they know that the plan doesn't, how they see the people leading it, and how much is already on their plate, before treating it as a people problem to manage.

This is my reading, Gabriel Lopez's, not a finding of the studies above.

Common questions

Is middle-manager resistance always bad for a change?

Not necessarily. One study of a telecom takeover argues resistance can be a check on over-optimistic plans, and another reads cynicism as a way of making sense of contradictions.

What makes middle managers turn against a change?

In a three-year case of radical change, middle managers moved from supporting their leaders to mutiny as they reassessed whether those leaders were legitimate, and their emotional reactions fed rising resistance.

Every summary on this page was written by Unfrozen from the study's abstract or full text and checked twice against the source. Loop coding is exploratory and provisional until an independent human coder checks it. Spot an error? Email info@unfreeze.us and it gets fixed.

More questions